Live data from Hacker News

Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

get-inscribe.com

191–200 of 251 posts

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#191
post #162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Two Yoots problem. Do you use d's in place of t's such as dees/dems/dose/dere? I have a heavy queens accent so you'll hear me say things like "deres tree uh dem ova dere."

Surprised to read this as a Queens thing, this sounds perfectly at home in the Midwest.

Yah thats definitely Minnesota, eh?

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are being naive. An Apple device makes dozens of network requests every minute or so to Apple. It is neigh on impossible to verify what is being requested or sent. Also unplugging the Internet and verifying that something still works does not mean the app won't phone home behind your back when it can. These things are designed to fail silently.

This is Hacker News. Computers are knowable, tractable things. It is trivial to know if a process is making network requests.

It's definitely not trivial to figure out what for, and what is being sent or received.

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fluidaudio implements Parakeet on ANE. I'd like to know how SpeechAnalyzer compares in speed. https://github.com/FluidInference/FluidAudio

Recently contributed a patch to FluidAudio that sped up Parakeet V2 and V3 to 320x and 282x faster than real time, respectively: https://github.com/FluidInference/FluidAudio/pull/507 That means one hour of audio transcribed in 11.25 and 12.75 seconds. The Inscribe post doesn't give a speed factor for SpeechAnalyzer. However, this Argmax blog post reports 70: https://www.argmaxinc.com/blog/apple-and-argmax Based on th…

The difference using an mp3 seems to be smaller: yap seems to use about the same time but fluidaudio seems to take twice as long. Do you happen to know why?

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#195

Whisper is the wrong model to benchmark against, or rather, there are better models that are state of the art now like Nemotron and Parakeet both by Nvidia, as well as Mistral's Voxtral and Cohere Transcribe. However, what's funny is, RIP to a lot of the paid apps that simply wrap Whisper, I'm sure Apple will make a native GUI such as a recorder app for macOS that obviates the need for these wrappers, which everyone…

Yes, poor comparison to what's now a relatively low end model.

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#197
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As an Australian, Apples voice models have always sucked. I've tried using stt (again) more recently and its improved, but i'm so tired of having to Americanize my voice to get it to figure out what the hell i'm saying.

As a Texan first, American second, I sympathize with this statement. Siri can't understand me probably 25% of the time. I use STT for iMessage while in the car, and half the time it will take 3+ times to either get it right or me give up, and hope to remember to text them by hand when I next stop.

What does this mean? When I pledged my oath to become a citizen, I had to promise to put America above all other allegiances. Is it in relation to allegiance in the general sense or some weird statement that only relates to STT?

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a Texan first, American second, I sympathize with this statement. Siri can't understand me probably 25% of the time. I use STT for iMessage while in the car, and half the time it will take 3+ times to either get it right or me give up, and hope to remember to text them by hand when I next stop.

What does this mean? When I pledged my oath to become a citizen, I had to promise to put America above all other allegiances. Is it in relation to allegiance in the general sense or some weird statement that only relates to STT?

I took it to mean “as someone with a Texas accent”

Re: Apple's new SpeechAnalyzer API, benchmarked against Whisper and its predecessor

#200
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also, this test is English-only, while a strong point of other models is to understand different languages without first having to say which one (so you don't need 3 different keyboard shortcuts if you wanna dictate in 3 languages day-to-day)

Reminds me of the time my neighbours must have wondered if I was having some kind of a breakdown when trying out really basic MacOS voice recognition back in the early 2000s. There was a keyboard shortcut and you could say something like "phone number for firstname lastname" and it would theoretically show you that phone number. Thing is it didn't seem to like a British accent, so I spent a good hour trying out diffe…

They were probably mainly wondering why you were doing this at their place instead of your own!
Post reply on HN