Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

github.com

31–40 of 70 posts

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#31

what visualization library is used -- looks cool -- maybe we could adapt it to other use cases that can benefit from a graph visualization

This: https://www.npmjs.com/package/three?activeTab=readme

according to packages: https://github.com/cosmtrek/mindwalk/blob/master/web/package...

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#33
post #32

Other than being aesthetically pleasing (which it doubtlessly is), what's the use case for this?

2019, in a comment about gource:

> It's pretty, but I can't think of anything I'd use it as a "tool" for. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21560013

Seems any time this sort of software comes up on, people can't let the use case be "this is aesthetically pleasing".

Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project.

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#34
post #32

Other than being aesthetically pleasing (which it doubtlessly is), what's the use case for this?

2019, in a comment about gource: > It's pretty, but I can't think of anything I'd use it as a "tool" for. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21560013 Seems any time this sort of software comes up on, people can't let the use case be "this is aesthetically pleasing". Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project…

> Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project.

I asked about the use case _because_ the readme states a problem but does not offer a solution to that problem as far as I could see.

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#35

Sort of like gource?

Wow, it's my first time learning it. The visualization seems similar.

gource seems to be on of those tools that people forget about. I don’t know if it’s the name or just simply that it’s the kind of thing you run once and think “that’s nice - what do I do with it?”. It’s not something you run regularly so it slowly disappears from memory.

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#36
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2019, in a comment about gource: > It's pretty, but I can't think of anything I'd use it as a "tool" for. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21560013 Seems any time this sort of software comes up on, people can't let the use case be "this is aesthetically pleasing". Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project…

> Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project. I asked about the use case _because_ the readme states a problem but does not offer a solution to that problem as far as I could see.

"The agent's understanding of the task becomes a shape you can see at a glance."

Use case is to monitor agents activity.

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#37
post #32

Other than being aesthetically pleasing (which it doubtlessly is), what's the use case for this?

2019, in a comment about gource: > It's pretty, but I can't think of anything I'd use it as a "tool" for. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21560013 Seems any time this sort of software comes up on, people can't let the use case be "this is aesthetically pleasing". Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project…

I agree with all of this, and gource is an excellent example, but this is still "what" and builds no case for a "why". Not even an anecdote like "I told the agent this and it completely misunderstood and did the other thing so I built this which you can use to undo the work after the fact."

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2019, in a comment about gource: > It's pretty, but I can't think of anything I'd use it as a "tool" for. - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21560013 Seems any time this sort of software comes up on, people can't let the use case be "this is aesthetically pleasing". Anyways, besides that, the README does clearly state "The Problem" and "The Idea" which outlines exactly why the author built this particular project…

I agree with all of this, and gource is an excellent example, but this is still "what" and builds no case for a "why". Not even an anecdote like "I told the agent this and it completely misunderstood and did the other thing so I built this which you can use to undo the work after the fact."

Because it’s fun and not everything has to exist for a reason other than that maybe? I built something in the same vein, and the way is because it’s neat. It serves no real purpose.

Re: Show HN: Mindwalk – Replay coding-agent sessions on a 3D map of your codebase

#39
A lot of people want a use case. One I think might be cool is some kind of spatial/represented comparison: let's see how two different models interact with the codebase (for the same problem), what they touched, and what they did. Or the same model, but averaged across 100 runs, so we can see how much variance there really is per task. Something along those lines sounds interesting to me.
Post reply on HN