[1] For a reasonable graphic example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:CIExy1931_srgb_gamut.png where grey is the entire visible spectrum and the coloured areas are the standard RGB colour space.
24-bit color sucks
31–40 of 90 posts
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#32Missing wood for trees. RGB displays are deliberately made to be 'good enough' rather than 'great'. None of them can display whole areas of the visible spectrum [1]. Before taking issue with tiny amounts of visible banding, just maybe it would be better if monitors could actually display a reasonable amount of the visible spectrum... [1] For a reasonable graphic example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:CIExy1931_srg…
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#33This is a fallacy. That the human eye cannot distinguish N different colours does not imply that a given colour space of >N colours contains every colour that the human eye can distinguish.
To give an equivalent example that is easier to understand, consider a colour space with 16.7 million shades of red. 16.7 million colours is more than the human eye can distinguish, but there are clearly many colours that the human eye can distinguish that are not in that colour space (notably shades of green, shades of blue, and combinations of red, green, and blue).
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#34On a Retina MacBook Pro using FireFox Nightly 20, I couldn't see the step.
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#35Earlier quoted context omitted.
I could, but barely. Not enough that this website made me care about the issue.
That's his point though, right: you are saying "meh, it's good enough".
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#36Re: 24-bit color sucks
#37With all due respect, I don't see the gradient break. may be because of that gray animation rotating behind that div?, this posts reminds me of that yesterday's HN parody.
Edit: I can't see it because my config does automatic dithering. See my other posts.
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#38Several monitors turn your 8-bpp image to a 6-bpp image.
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#39Am I the only person who couldn't tell the difference in that horizontal gradient example?
Of course much of the media we consume has quantized colour, streamed videos especially don't really stand up to any kind of close examination using today's displays, never mind futuristic ones. Banding from limited gamut is not the big problem here, there are much bigger elephants.
Re: 24-bit color sucks
#4024bit is fine. It's <200dpi that has to die.