Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 42 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#31
post #16

Fine for my closed source stuff, but my open source work is specifically meant to be viewable, even by non-technical people doing recruitment or looking over my portfolio. I've put up with a lot of stuff, but this would be my personal last straw.

On top of the that now most of the open source contributers are assholes. they are insulting people as well.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#32

I think it’s been functionally login-only for a while, unfortunately. Any time I try to use the site while logged out I immediately hit all sorts of rate limits and spam prevention measures. Issues and pull requests stop loading almost immediately. Searches are extremely restricted, like i think literally one search is all you get sometimes unless you login. It’s hard to tell how much of this is intentional and how m…

> like i think literally one search is all you get sometimes unless you login

Lucky you - search never seems to work for me anonymously, and even when logged in the search isn't great.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#33
It's the new scraping tax. The delicate balance of the open web is completely broken right now because platforms are getting hammered by bots. Sometimes i wonder how long before the entire internet ends up behind a mandatory login or a paywall just to protect server bandwidth?

I really appreciate that HN still just uses temporary rate limits. You get the occasional "sorry" text, but as soon as traffic drops or your IP changes, you can read without logging in.

I wish more platforms stuck to temporary rate limits instead of building permanent walled gardens.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#35
Depends on what you mean by login wall. They are, technically, behind a login/auth wall as you can only make 60 requests to their API per hour. Scrapping these days is extremely challenging as defenses do in-depth checks on your browser to make sure you are a "real" person.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#36
If you need to just offer free access to your open source repo, gitea is a nice alternative and super easy to self host. Github also has the community, which you lose, true, but it depends on what matters more to you. I can help you setup gitea really fast if you're interested

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub preparing to go behind a login wall?

#37
I mean, I'm guilty too. Claude code scrapes everything in sight whenever I search for something.

I've written a small tool to query Github to see if a particular feature has been released for an open source project. I had to use an API token to not get immediately blocked. But I don't think rate limits are new for Github.

Post reply on HN