Live data from Hacker News

CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

comaps.app

161–170 of 221 posts

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does it compare to AllTrails in America?

Unless I’m mistaken they both ultimately use OpenStreetMap data. So, effectively the same coverage of trails. AllTrails has its whole review system sitting on top of course.

This is correct. Tools might however display them slightly different, have different update schedules or make different cartographic choices (e.g. not showing node networks or something)

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#162

perfect timing. i was using OpenStreetMap for my ios running app and I found out that there is a cap so I ended up switching to a paid solution and have been trying to build something like comaps by downloading all the tiles

Don't download all the tiles, that is useless.

Look into protomaps instead. One ~100GB archive for the entire world

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#163
post #150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To what end? I can think of 10 reasons immediately off the top of my head, but it’s far easier to fill existing open source projects with agent contributors for most of them. Do you really need someone to rhyme out why state actors do what they do?

An example would be very interesting and yes explaining what they’re up to would be interesting as well. Otherwise it sounds like a made up conspiracy theory….

Your accusatory ignorance is not mine to relieve.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XZ_Utils_backdoor

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#164
post #120

Does anybody know of a feasible alternative to Google Timeline?

Half of the solution at least on Android is https://gpslogger.app. Then you need to find a way to render the data to a map, such as with https://dawarich.app. Looks like the last time I looked at that project (and wasn't quite sold on it) was 1.5 years ago, so time for a second look.

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#165
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> what's an extra field? That is not a flag "is the crossing wheelchair accessible?". It's user created picture or text. This can be any kind of content, abusive, regulated by law, spam, subjective for chat control "age verification" controls, copyrighted and so on. Moderation is a hard topic. Only very small communities can do that well.

To be fair there are examples of freeform text tags in OpenStreetMap already, e.g. “description”.

Which is hard to get to, doesn't even render on some apps at all, it's easier to automatically or manually moderate as it has a more defined purpose and it's pure text (not meant for personal feelings towards the place, not meant for rating etc).

Absolutely, can be abused. But there can be thousands of reviews of a pizza place, with text, surprising languages, slang, pictures... But only one description.

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#166
post #52

One of the main things that keeps me from using essentially all OSM-based mapping apps as my primary is that search seems incredibly bad. I can't blend city and name, road and category, can't usually filter by features or open time, and results are almost always something like: - a result 500 feet away that sounds nothing like what you searched for - a result 23 miles away that shares one word but nothing else - a re…

Could you try https://cartes.app and share your search terms and expectations ? We're using Photon, an OpenSearch search engine. We've build a dictionary of place categories to help in-browser with FuseJS. Also thinking about using embeddings to complement this.

Cartes search and user experience was surprisingly good! Well done. I was caught off guard by having the requirement for a Bluesky account for reviews instead of something open source/federated but wasn't able to read the explanation page as it was french only, but I think the international version is still work in progress, so I'll gladly return in the future.

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even for driving the major apps are crappy about routes. I was on Foothills Parkway a while ago and wanted to keep Apple Maps running just as a "miles/time remaining" indicator. It can't do anything other than fastest route, with the option to ignore highways. So unless you set a waypoint halfway between every single entry/exit, it will want to get off the parkway and take US 321 instead. You can manually set up the…

I had the same issue planning roadtrips where the journey is the destination. I’ve paid for apps like InRoute despite poor UX, inability to access my routes from desktop, and zero collaboration support I got increasingly frustrated looking for a replacement that I made https://plotalong.app in my spare time so that my wife and I could plan and save our motorcycle trips together. We still have to add the occasional “v…

Very cool! That solves creating and saving a route with extra navigation waypoints, so the other thing I'd want out of it is a native app with CarPlay where I can get total time/distance remaining, time/distance to next stop, and the option to pick which waypoints count as "stops" (versus just being there to control the route). I see there's a GPX export but I'm sure that won't handle the waypoints how I want it to. Guessing native apps are out of scope though?

If you're ever near the Smokies, here's a loop from Knoxville through Foothills Parkway (west section), Tail of the Dragon, and Cherohala Skyway, with a detour up to Maple Springs Overlook (site of a popular annual hill climb).

https://plotalong.app/maps/b53f3c01-4e3c-4b52-a560-4a3259e08...

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#168
OSM is great as a map, but the biggest thing keeping me from switching from Google Maps to any OSM solution is the "white pages". My most common use case for a maps app is location-based search.

Having a complete and updated registry of businesses with operating hours is the bare minimum, and OSM apps already struggle with that. I also want pictures of the establishment, pictures of the menu for restaurants, and price estimates for fuel and hotels.

I understand the cost of hosting and moderating that stuff is enormous, but that's what it will take for me to finally convert.

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#169
post #115

Sorry for the slight off-topic: Is there any standard protocol/format for "layers" that could be added to such Map apps? Let's say I want to write a plugin to add my own kind of data, and then I want to export this new kind of data so that someone can import them. Or I want to create a website with my own data on top of existing one.

This is all OSM-based. OSM is one big pile of data - we don't do layers. It is also best to add it directly into OSM, importing data afterwards is tricky. My talk at Why25 should be a good intro ( https://media.ccc.de/v/why2025-198-openstreetmap-for-beginne... ), but the OSM-wiki also contains some valuable sources: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tags , https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Map_features There are…

This is incredibly helpful. Thank you!

Re: CoMaps – FOSS Offline Maps

#170
post #5

Relevant thread from yesterday's thread on the original project this was forked from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48794575 https://itsfoss.com/news/organic-maps-fork-comaps/ > Despite being advertised as a community-driven project, key decisions, including financial management, partnerships (with Kayak, for instance), and the inclusion of proprietary components in the code were made by a small group of shareh…

Nitpick: Organic Map is not original project. It's a fork of Maps.me.

Interesting, I didn't realize Maps.me used to be open-source! I suppose this is the code (from five years ago): https://github.com/mapsme/omim
Post reply on HN