Live data from Hacker News

Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

writerbeware.blog

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#11
> The catch, as you’ll doubtless have guessed, is that the author has to pay a fee for their appearance, variously described as a “spot fee” or a “spotlight fee” or a “spot-securing fee” or a “participation fee”.

Am I being too naive to assume that legitimate book clubs shouldn't be doing this anyway - or is all online activity just a way of generating income now?

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's life I'm afraid - no system that rewards participation can be entirely free of people taking advantage of it somehow. It's an unavoidable cost that we pay to get the benefits. The best we can usually do is to incentivize good behaviour sufficiently that the percentage of bad actors is very low, using rewards and/or punishments as appropriate.

Google could obliterate these scammers.

Aren’t they the biggest scammers on earth, though?

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#14
post #3

With the whole ecosystem stacked against new and indie authors, and AI getting so good I can see why some people could easily fall for this. I made the tough decision at the start of my Sci-Fi novel writing career to work 100% on the book and 0% on the marketing. It meant I got zero traction and attention in the market (except by word of mouth), and I had to keep my day job, but totally took away all the stress and a…

Do you have a link to your books so we can check them out?

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#15
post #3

With the whole ecosystem stacked against new and indie authors, and AI getting so good I can see why some people could easily fall for this. I made the tough decision at the start of my Sci-Fi novel writing career to work 100% on the book and 0% on the marketing. It meant I got zero traction and attention in the market (except by word of mouth), and I had to keep my day job, but totally took away all the stress and a…

Do you have a link to your books so we can check them out?

There's a link in his profile: https://rodyne.com/

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's life I'm afraid - no system that rewards participation can be entirely free of people taking advantage of it somehow. It's an unavoidable cost that we pay to get the benefits. The best we can usually do is to incentivize good behaviour sufficiently that the percentage of bad actors is very low, using rewards and/or punishments as appropriate.

Google could obliterate these scammers.

A scammer recognizes another scammer from Afar

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#18
post #3

With the whole ecosystem stacked against new and indie authors, and AI getting so good I can see why some people could easily fall for this. I made the tough decision at the start of my Sci-Fi novel writing career to work 100% on the book and 0% on the marketing. It meant I got zero traction and attention in the market (except by word of mouth), and I had to keep my day job, but totally took away all the stress and a…

Oh, excellent! I thought I was the only author (idiotic enough) to give away my books for free. I choose to call it altruism, but the truth is that I got sick of the whole marketing-and-promotion meat grinder a long while back and decided I wanted to write books I wanted to read, rather than writing what someone else thought they could sell. I am now proud to call myself a Hobbyist Indie Author. Perhaps we could start an insurgency together?

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#19

> The catch, as you’ll doubtless have guessed, is that the author has to pay a fee for their appearance, variously described as a “spot fee” or a “spotlight fee” or a “spot-securing fee” or a “participation fee”. Am I being too naive to assume that legitimate book clubs shouldn't be doing this anyway - or is all online activity just a way of generating income now?

That's the very next sentence: "Needless to say, real book clubs don’t charge fees to their guests".

Re: Return of the Nigerian Prince Redux: Beware Book Club and Book Review Scams (2025)

#20

The need to defend against scams and abuse is a cost distributed across all of society - it’d be amazing if there were a way for all to share the costs without creating a giant firewall to wall off the bad countries. How does one take the good and reject the bad? Even our immune systems still get beaten by cancers.

Get rid of financial inequality.
Post reply on HN