Live data from Hacker News

America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

derekthompson.org

21–30 of 196 posts

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#21
post #2

So, we're about to have Great Depression 2 and WW3? Fun.

Sometimes I wish Strauss–Howe theory hadn't been hijacked. It seems noteworthy how similar (cyclical?) things are even if it's a coincidence..

What do you mean hijacked? I'm not familiar with that theory.

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#23
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You might be surprised to hear that wealth concentration was worse a hundred years ago than it is now. It's very easy to assume otherwise when the numbers are so much larger now across the board. https://americanbusinesshistory.org/superwealth-a-historical...

yes almost all americans now have running water and indoor toilets except we have more homeless than ever so they don't even have that with taxes slashed for billionaires and safety-nets for food and healthcare being destroyed, we are actually headed back to 1926 on purpose

Feels like a bit of a dramatization.

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#26
post #14

I an a completely unabashed leftist who has been "radicalized" (if you call free school lunches "radical", which apparently it is in modern America) by seeing the rapidly accelerating wealth and income inequality since 2008. I mean it really kciked off in the 1970s but the effects post-2008 became impossible to ignore. In the spirit of all models are wroong but some models are useful and that generational politics is…

> talked to the rising anger in young people at the lack of opportunity, the possibility that they'd never own a house or have a good-paying job or they'd have a family. The disillusionment and anger has only grown. This should be the absolutely only thing that Democrats talk about. Every single day, with a big graph and call in number, so people can call in to say if this was fixed for them or not. And if it's not f…

> It's insane they aren't using this opportunity.

Instead they're taking the opportunity to be insane. But the faithful are not allowed to admit that.

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#27
post #13

No offense but outside of money does the US have anything going for it?

Freedom to say (almost) anything, publicly, including criticism of the elite and powerful.

Freedom to do, to create a business with far fewer roadblocks than in, say, Europe.

Freedom to go, to travel anywhere in a really large country, with no borders or restrictions.

Yeah, you can quote me all the caveats. They're there; I don't deny them. But: Freedom to say, freedom to do, and freedom to go. Those are really big deals.

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#28
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You might be surprised to hear that wealth concentration was worse a hundred years ago than it is now. It's very easy to assume otherwise when the numbers are so much larger now across the board. https://americanbusinesshistory.org/superwealth-a-historical...

yes almost all americans now have running water and indoor toilets except we have more homeless than ever so they don't even have that with taxes slashed for billionaires and safety-nets for food and healthcare being destroyed, we are actually headed back to 1926 on purpose

The definition of homeless was quite different at that time --- note that there was an entire class of people defined as hobos/migrant workers who began the year helping out with cutting lumber and harvesting maple sugar in the winter, then working south to help with the planting of truck crops (lettuce, spinach, broccoli, peas...) in the spring, pruning fruit trees and harvesting early crops in the summer, then in the fall helping with the harvests and picking cotton and so forth, then helping to plant cover crops and so forth and moving north to repeat the process.

Louis L'Amour writes on this a bit in his wonderful book:

https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/828165.Education_of_a...

Re: America, 1926: A forgotten 100-year-old report

#30

I read Sinclair Lewis' Babbit last year and it was kind of depressing how little has changed since 1922. The political climate (at least as portrayed in the novel) seemed eerily similar to now. Maybe we continually go through oscillations.

I'm shocked how much the average American knows about how things work. Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty. I'm not surprised how quickly Americans are giving up their liberty.
Post reply on HN