I’ve seen a few posts about a “better social network” tried a few even thought about making my own. It seems hard to get them off the ground. I wonder if the answer to the enshittification of social networks is “no social network at all”.
Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
21–30 of 68 posts
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#22I came across a line in the Social Contract that caught my attention: “The platforms that dominate today have drifted from their original promise. Feeds are flooded with content from accounts no one follows.”
I respectfully disagree with that. IMO the problem lies in the opposite direction. The content we see on these sites is driven by algorithms that reward popular posts and influencers. This creates a system of “stars” and “fans,” which does not foster genuine connections.
The original internet promised to give equal voices to all and allow users to see things they might otherwise miss. When I encounter a new social network like yours, especially one as elegant as this, I secretly hope it will restore that original promise.
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#23Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#24Since you've actually started a social media site, I wonder if you have any insight on that? You say you believe in this project; what is it that you think is valuable about letting everyone talk to everyone, as opposed to exclusive and curated spaces for people that semi-self-select based on community interests and values, like forums? Separately, why do you think that removing organizations/brands and psuedo users is going to be the crux of the solution?
Honestly looking to have my mind changed. But mostly just curious.
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#25Is this site inclusive of nonhuman identities? [0] It seems incredibly focused on "real humans" etc, which is (common...), but my real identity doesn't exist in the physical world. (There are also multiple of them thanks to DID, but that tends to require a significant rearchitecture to accommodate) [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otherkin
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#26I wonder why you change the links from the internal ones to this format https://piecesof.me/p/5b2w8x6sn2mwkdhppfusvqsf8z5h1t ?
The writing is quite nice. I don't understand the "Docs". And I'd suggest to make it very easy to write my first post. The big editor is a bit scary.
also here: https://piecesof.me/videos - where do I get prompted to upload my own video?
Anyway, good luck! Let's see how long I can stick around.
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#27Is this site inclusive of nonhuman identities? [0] It seems incredibly focused on "real humans" etc, which is (common...), but my real identity doesn't exist in the physical world. (There are also multiple of them thanks to DID, but that tends to require a significant rearchitecture to accommodate) [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otherkin
We'll have to open a committee to launch an investigation to produce a report about whether accounts held by Otherkin should be allowed. Stay tuned and thanks for your patience.
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#28- the biggest challenge you are facing is overcoming the double network effect
- in order for any of em to take off, you need to get me and my friends and their friends and so on
- one way to do this is to start a social network only for a small niche. could be anything. startups only! designers only etc and scale it up one category at a time to let the network effects come into the picture
- that is how you build a social media with 1M+ users
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#29- i see a 100 social networks advertised daily on reddit, HN etc - the biggest challenge you are facing is overcoming the double network effect - in order for any of em to take off, you need to get me and my friends and their friends and so on - one way to do this is to start a social network only for a small niche. could be anything. startups only! designers only etc and scale it up one category at a time to let the…
Re: Show HN: Pieces – Social network for people
#30The more I see of social media, the more I'm convinced that it's not really a fulfilling way to share and socialize on the internet. I've come to believe that anything that can platform every voice on the planet forces noise to drown out signal. Since you've actually started a social media site, I wonder if you have any insight on that? You say you believe in this project; what is it that you think is valuable about…
I kinda miss the "old" social media, where it was media and also social... you would open whatever (facebook, myspace, instagram...) and you'd see your friends, plates of what they're eating, some attention seeking statuses, wedding photos, invites to birthdays, etc.
I have no idea if people stopped posting all that or if algorithm hid all that content behind random content it wanted to push instead, so you get zero of that but a lot of random news stories, "reels" and random videos from influences you don't follow and are not interested in, and basically a lot of not-social stuff. I know there's more money for the social network if they show me artificially protracted diy wideos and "you won't believe..." crap, but that made me leave one "social" network after another.