Live data from Hacker News

German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

smithsonianmag.com

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#21
post #10

I recently learned about using mussels for buttons when I visited the Mississippi River Museum in Dubuque, Iowa and have been wondering since: can Zebra Mussels be used for buttons? That would create (even more) economic incentive to go after them.

you can use anything for buttons if you are dedicated enough and have the right tools

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#22
post #10

I recently learned about using mussels for buttons when I visited the Mississippi River Museum in Dubuque, Iowa and have been wondering since: can Zebra Mussels be used for buttons? That would create (even more) economic incentive to go after them.

Probably not as economical as cheap plastic buttons, and harvesting them at low cost would likely disrupt native species too

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#24
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> TLDR: Consequently many freshwater mussel species are now extinct The problem with the DR part of TLDR is that you miss a lot of detail. There are more factors than just the button industry. > To survive past the larvae stage, they must become parasites that attach themselves to fish. If the fish populations are declining, that oftentimes has an indirect effect on mussel abundance > the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers…

It's sad, but the entire culture is devolving into requiring a dumbed down summary or tl;dr version of everything.

Those who really understood it need the least words to explain it.

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#25
post #23

Is the fact that he was of German descent material to how the events transpired? Not sure why it's even mentioned in the headline.

I think it's because it's the Smithsonian magazine. Smithsonian celebrates the origins of people and things that shaped some part of American history.

It's significant that "Boepple immigrated to the United States in the late 1880s, resolving to search for more of these freshwater mussels."

And he was German. Lots of Germans emigrated to the USA, especially around that time. so it's important context of who this man was

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#26
post #10

I recently learned about using mussels for buttons when I visited the Mississippi River Museum in Dubuque, Iowa and have been wondering since: can Zebra Mussels be used for buttons? That would create (even more) economic incentive to go after them.

An economic incentive to hunt a particular species does not result in a decrease in population. What you have instead is an economic incentive to breed large populations in uncontrolled conditions, likely on public land, which then get abandoned and/or released when you realize the economic incentive has made your invasive species problem far, far worse.

This has happened many times throughout history.

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#27
post #23

Is the fact that he was of German descent material to how the events transpired? Not sure why it's even mentioned in the headline.

The story starts with a German man, John Boepple, in his button shop in Germany. He immigrates to the US with the resolve to search for more freshwater mussels. So yes, it is relevant if you're interested in telling a story of the events that transpired.

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#29
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> TLDR: Consequently many freshwater mussel species are now extinct The problem with the DR part of TLDR is that you miss a lot of detail. There are more factors than just the button industry. > To survive past the larvae stage, they must become parasites that attach themselves to fish. If the fish populations are declining, that oftentimes has an indirect effect on mussel abundance > the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers…

Regarding the dams, I recommend the book "Cadillac Desert" to anyone even remotely curious about the background and scale of water projects in the US. It's not boring despite the what the subject matter might suggest.

That's about the US West. It might as well be a different country, with respect to water. East of, say, Omaha, the concern is more getting rid of water than collecting it.

Re: German button maker searched rivers of American Midwest for valuable shells

#30
post #23

Is the fact that he was of German descent material to how the events transpired? Not sure why it's even mentioned in the headline.

Because the article is about more than just the buttons.

For Boepple, buttons were the family business. At his shop in Germany, he had learned to craft them out of wood, shell, horn and bone. But pearl buttons brought in the biggest profits. When a German tariff put him out of business, Boepple became one of the nearly 1.5 million Germans who immigrated to America in the 1880s. “They each brought their own skills,” Joy says. “Mr. Boepple was a button maker.”

Post reply on HN