Live data from Hacker News

PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts

kotaku.com

231–235 of 235 posts

Re: PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts

#232
post #223
post #209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay, but who do you donate to in the case of a movie or show? Because for authors and musicians I agree with your take. I wish more musicians were on Bandcamp, and more authors sold e-books directly from their website.

Even with musicians it can be tricky. Imagine an album with various classical pieces performed by different orchestras. Not only are there the conductors and the musicians of the orchestras, but the album also wouldn't have existed without the sound engineers and recording crews and the composers... Even authors are dependent on their editors, so the idea of 'giving money to the people who create the things we like'…

Yeah, but do all those people get residuals? When you buy a real copy, who gets money from that?

Re: PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No — both the person who pulls the trigger and the person who gives the order are criminals. Sony created a contract where this was possible, is who sold the product to customers, and is physically carrying out the act. They deserve every bit of blame.

'Criminals'? Get a grip.

to be fair, if you went to a movie store, bought a movie (and unbeknownst to you there was some note on the counter that said the store reserved the right to take your movie from you), when the stores employees break into your house one day and forcefully take the DVDs from you, you might use a similar word…

Re: PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts

#234
post #223

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even with musicians it can be tricky. Imagine an album with various classical pieces performed by different orchestras. Not only are there the conductors and the musicians of the orchestras, but the album also wouldn't have existed without the sound engineers and recording crews and the composers... Even authors are dependent on their editors, so the idea of 'giving money to the people who create the things we like'…

Yeah, but do all those people get residuals? When you buy a real copy, who gets money from that?

Not sure about music, but I’ve dated an author and her contract was for 10% royalties, and she had to arrange any payments to other rights-holders (e.g. photographer) but not the editor.

Re: PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts

#235
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder why their license affects your local copy of a purchased product. Imagine a supermarket losing the contract to sell Nescafé, so Nestlé comes into your house to take their coffee. Okay, Nestlé would totally do this anyway, but it’s bizarre.

Because it's not a purchased product. It's a sub-license of Apple's license for you to temporarily play a work.

Okay, but then it’s not a sale. Words mean something, and selling me something should mean what everyone expects it to.

Post reply on HN