Live data from Hacker News

30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

theintercept.com

431–440 of 577 posts

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#431
Can’t read the article without signing up.

On the topic—I’m shocked. Seems like this judge missed the last 40 years of the internet. People organize on all manner of subjects on the net with silly names, and around all subjects. Failure to see this, makes terrorists of us all.

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#432

[flagged]

Question: Do you take everything Trump declares as the absolute truth?

If Trump designates Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster to be a terrorist organization tomorrow, do you believe their church members to be terrorists?

This is a fundamental question, because at the very core of the case, these protesters have been labeled terrorists belonging to a "Antifa cell", aka. terrorist cell.

Do you believe that a anti-ICE protester transporting scream rockets is equivalent to a ISIS member transporting pipe bombs?

It is very much possible to have opinions, without basing your opinions on feelings. If Trump tomorrow declares that the sky is golden metallic, and that all humans can fly, disagreeing isn't opposing facts just because Trump has declared those as the new facts.

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#434
post #5

It's pretty straightforward that if someone tells you to hide something because they've been arrested and they think it ties them to some criminal act, and then you hide it, you're an accessory to the crime. 30 years for that seems harsh though I anticipate they will be pardoned by the next Democratic Party President. Describing such an act without the obvious context is a pretty good way to point out that it's parti…

I would love to see a detailed comparison of everyone who comments on this issue vs their comments on the age verification issue. For the latter, people bend over backwards to make it a free speech issue yet so many bend over backwards on this issue to argue this 30 year sentence was good actually because they were an accessory to domestic terrorism.

My hypothesis is that these two groups are mostly the same people.

Tad Stoermer, lecturer on American history and author of A Resistance History of the United States summed this up [1]. The person in question here wasn't even at the event. They moved a box of publications and from all this the Federal government created an domestic terrorist organization out of whole cloth (ie Antifa).

What people seem to refuse to accept is that "terrorist" is a political designation, nothing more. It's basically saying "we don't like this person or organization". Were the standards of today around in the 1960s, every civil rights organization would've been labelled domestic terrorists.

The comparisons to January 6 are apt because that was an attempted coup in which people died. The harshest sentences were Enrique Tarrio (ringleader, 22 years), Stewart Rhodes (seditious conspiracy, 18 years) and Ethan Nordean (seditious conspiracy, 18 years). All pardoned by the way.

Yet the people who want to defend 30 years for moving a box of zines by someone who wasn't at the event is astounding.

[1]: https://www.tiktok.com/@tadstoermer/video/765517473106636316...

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#436

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The Biden administration started targeting "right-wing terrorists" Where can I read more about this?

https://www.complexsystemspodcast.com/episodes/splc-financia...

The first few examples aren't every sympathetic (SBF, some pedo, and George Santos), and their argument doesn't appear to be reinforced by the evidence. Though the source is quite long so perhaps they decided to bury the lede.

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#437
post #401

USA is such a weird place these days. Is there a way back to sanity once this administration ends?

Here's the thing: The traditional / establishment democrats have blindly believed that you can negotiate with people like Trump, because of decorum. Establishment candidates have been more occupied with taking the moral high-road, even if that resulted in loss after loss. There's this ingrained belief that if you just play nice with republicans, they'll play nice back. And that was valid for a long, long time. The pr…

No, it's worse than that. Establishment Democrats are complicit in what Trump is doing. This went so far as to intentionally lose the presidential election in 2024 rather than oppose genocide. How can Trump both be a fascist and an existential threat and a preferable outcome to stopping genocide?

For years, the Democrats have sold this "electability" lie, that the only electable Democrats are "moderates" or "centrists". This was never true and it was just an excuse for the same people funding both parties to make the Democrats the controlled opposition.

What we've seen in the last year is the right democratic socialists ousting incumbents in primaries and defeating establishment candidates. This movement is undeniably popular and what do establishment Democrats do? They side with Republicans in saying that socialism is an existential threat to the US.

As for your last point, I think we're going to find out what happens sooner than many think. MAGA is a cult and cults never survive intact when their leader dies. There's nobody to take his place so the jmost likely outcome is a descent into factionalism and the party splinters for a time until Trump 2.0 can once again unite the factions.

But we should never forget that establishment Democrats are siding and will side with Republicans to defend the current system.

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#438
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you think that this was a protest then yeah it's worrying. The feds case, which they did win convictions based on, was that they were terrorists who set off fireworks to lure police into an ambush, and there weren't more casualties because one of the members shot early and only injured one cop. An accessory to this who hid evidence is also part of the crime in the Feds case Is this embellished by the Feds? I think…

"Lure police into an ambush" is quite a stretch. It's quite normal to do noise demonstrations outside jails/prisons to show solidarity with the captives, the captives will often times knock on the windows to communicate back. In fact there were noise demonstrations outside the Delaney Hall ICE jail in New Jersey just this month, which you may have heard about. The mischaracterization of fireworks as "explosives" is a…

If you don’t think fireworks are explosives you’re buying the wrong ones.

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#439

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The pardoned Jan. 6 rioters had a lot of far worse plans that were foiled which could have resulted in more casualties. There was lots of evidence several of them planned to kidnap sitting congressmen and women. Do you know why they were pardoned and this zine hider got 30 years? Must just be a quirk of the justice system...

[flagged]

IIRC these were state charges, not federal.

Only chance at the zine-hider seeing actual justice is texas doing a blue flip(hell freezing over).

Re: 30-year sentence for transporting zines is a five-alarm fire for free speech

#440

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The pardoned Jan. 6 rioters had a lot of far worse plans that were foiled which could have resulted in more casualties. There was lots of evidence several of them planned to kidnap sitting congressmen and women. Do you know why they were pardoned and this zine hider got 30 years? Must just be a quirk of the justice system...

[flagged]

> Gretchen Whitmer

A sitting politician was nearly kidnapped by a group of people who all wanted to torture her, but let's focus on the one FBI agent.

Post reply on HN