A very reasonable policy, prevents AI Slop from flooding the platform due to misaligned creator / consumer incentives
Tidal AI Policy
11–20 of 359 posts
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#12> Tidal will accept AI-generated music
Tl;dr. Another one bites the dust.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#13Love that they don't pay any royalties for AI music right now, unlike Spotify.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#14> Tidal defines AI-generated music as music that is wholly or substantially generated by generative artificial intelligence.
I think this needs more clarity. I can think of a lot of different ways AI is used in music today as a part of the song generation process and not sure whether or not this definition would apply to it. They specifically mention developments in "text-prompted generation" but if anything that confuses the issue more, for example what about training on specific music.
This isn't a comment on how expansive or narrow the definition should be, just that they need to spell it out more to allow for consistent application (to say nothing of enforcement). If someone uses ChatGPT for lyrics, but writes the instrumentals themselves, does this policy apply? I genuinely have no idea.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#15> Tidal will accept AI-generated music. > Tidal will hold AI-generated music to a higher standard of content integrity. We will not tolerate AI-generated music that exploits an individual’s or group’s music, name or likeness, deceives listeners, or diminishes the quality of our service. I think this is a very reasonable approach, and probably also the best way to treat AI-powered copyright infringement as a whole. Ju…
The flood of AI music on their platform is becuase people can make money off it. If you turn off that faucet you stop the flooding.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#16> Tidal will accept AI-generated music Tl;dr. Another one bites the dust.
it won't be monetized so there's zero incentive to upload AI slop to Tidal
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#17I'm a Tidal subscriber, something like this is needed.
My Tidal "feed" is full of new releases that are clearly AI-generated. They use the same artist name as artists that I really like, but the music is clearly not from the artist as advertised.
I have no problem with AI-generated music, I just don't want someone trying to spoof the artists I am interested in.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#18> Tidal defines AI-generated music as music that is wholly or substantially generated by generative artificial intelligence. I think this needs more clarity. I can think of a lot of different ways AI is used in music today as a part of the song generation process and not sure whether or not this definition would apply to it. They specifically mention developments in "text-prompted generation" but if anything that con…
[flagged]
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#19Love that they don't pay any royalties for AI music right now, unlike Spotify.
So, their incentive is to promote AI music, since they don't have to pay royalties for them.
Re: Tidal AI Policy
#20Allow AI, but require labeling as such, and demonetize. Would love for YouTube to follow suit on this
Would you really like to take action and earn less money? Morality is dead...