Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

xcancel.com

11–20 of 30 posts

Re: Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

#11
The interesting thing here is that Amodei is implicitly admitting he foresees open-weight models (and not "open-source", please...) reaching Mythos-equivalent capability before much longer.

Which, I mean, d'uh; if you've been paying attention it's not a wild forecast.

But it's interesting that he's admitting it.

Re: Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

#13
post #6

Paraphrasing him, he says that open source software which tool tens or hundreds of millions to build should be classified as a different category. And the implication being they should be banned. Why?

'These tools will become dangerously powerful, which is why nobody should be allowed to have them except through buying them from specifically me' seems a lot like motivated reasoning to me.

Re: Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

#15
post #8

They just want US authorities to ban big corporations from using models like GLM etc. so that they can keep selling their overpriced tokens. Funnily enough, a ban like this would close to impossible to enforce on individuals, so I guess their lobbying efforts will soon be met by lobbying efforts from big corporations that are losing from this.

Completely stopping people from using open source models is impossible, but if it became a federal law there could be incredible pressure exerted on US companies. For example, OpenRouter might be compelled to not accept open source requests on threat of fines.

I'm just a guy who writes code and geopolitics and big business is usually above my head

That said, I have a suspicion that if the US exerts that kind of pressure on US companies, they will just pivot to using offshore contractors that are doing the things they want

Re: Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

#19

(2023) Testimony from July 25, 2023 U.S. Senate hearing "Oversight of A.I.: Principles for Regulation." https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/committee-activity/hearings...

Do we have recent commentary on open-weight from the Anthropic founding team?

Re: Anthropic CEO: Open-Source AI is getting dangerous (2023)

#20
Creating AI monopolies is more dangerous. How much better would it be for environment and privacy if instead of concentrating AI power in few data centers it's distributed across all compute and memory devices? If just few players control the narrative and the infrastructure it's a single point of failure or worse a single point of control. Bad for democracy, society, pushes inequality.
Post reply on HN