Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

reuters.com

531–540 of 1001 posts

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#531

Reminds me a bit of the anecdote of Steve Jobs complaining about people ripping off the Mac GUI, in the mid to late 1980s, when he gave no public acknowledgement to the work done by Xerox on the Alto and Star operating system. "you're trying to rip off what I've already ripped off!" Crawl the whole Internet to build a gargantuan sized LLM and then complain you're being copied...

Yeah, the whole AI industry is just people ripping off each other.. Started by AI companies gulping up all the information that technical or altruistic people shared on the Internet in the past 40 years to help other fellow humans, then moved to AI companies consuming pirated and copyrighted material and now its AI companies ripping off each other.

Information really does want to become free, but AI companies want to be gatekeepers. Long term I bet on the open weights to win, as the more sustainable approach.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#532
post #521

There is so much hot air and guff around AI, so please if you don't believe me verify yourself, but GLM 5.2 is "good enough" to replace Claude Code / Codex. No it's not frontier, but it's beyond that point that Opus 4.5 hit where people started to really depend on Claude Code around last November time. It's also a fraction of the cost of a Claude Code subscription especially when you account for how high the usage li…

It seems more like the Chinese companies ar playing the dirty game, distilling through bot accounts, not letting real competition across their firewall.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#533

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But if you show them a jailbreak of their model that bypasses their safety, they'll tell you that any model can eventually be jailbroken so don't worry about safety. They claim two things: 1) The specific, available jailbreak for Fable 5 is not dangerous - this has been confirmed by multiple experts, and there is no credible evidence against this claim (in other words, Anthropic is probably correct) 2) It is imposs…

Supposedly the details of the ‘jailbreak’ are that you give it insecure code and say “fix this code”, and it does, and then you ask it for test scripts and that’s effectively an exploit against the unfixed code. If true then I have no idea how anyone’s going to release a useful model that doesn’t have the same jailbreak. https://www.theregister.com/security/2026/06/15/feds-freaked...

If that's the extent of the jailbreak, then the government should have banned every existing LLM - their story only makes sense if there's some Fable-specific capability that got unlocked.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#534
I'll just leave it here: "Anthropic's downloading of over seven million books from pirate sites like LibGen constituted infringement, the judge ruled, rejecting Anthropic's "research purpose" defense: "You can't just bless yourself by saying I have a research purpose and, therefore, go and take any textbook you want."

https://www.joneswalker.com/en/insights/blogs/ai-law-blog/wh...

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#535

Here's what is happening: Chinese resellers are offering Claude tokens at 70-90% below official Anthropic API prices. They achieve this by reselling capacity from pooled Claude Max accounts, payments fraud, and also reselling the model output & reasoning chains to various Chinese labs. They are subsidizing model access in exchange for user logs and reasoning traces, which they then sell as training data, allowing the…

Interesting article - your discussion from the time:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48165492

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#536
Being absolute ass to entire internet as you scour everything with no regard to common protocols - fine

Getting treated exactly same by competition - "we need rapid, coordinated action among industry players, policymakers and the global AI community."

Absolute scum. And the gall of going "oh buh it can be used for military, quick govt do something".

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#537

There's two basic kinds of distillation: 1) the massive [and dumb] method where you ask a question and use the answer as reinforcement (Black Box), and 2) more targeted distillation where you use one model to directly inform/train/guide another model (RLAIF). The latter is basically fine-tuning the model with direction from another model. Thousands of businesses do this every day to fine-tune. This is almost certainl…

> But if you show them a jailbreak of their model that bypasses their safety, they'll tell you that any model can eventually be jailbroken so don't worry about safety. They claim two things: 1) The specific, available jailbreak for Fable 5 is not dangerous - this has been confirmed by multiple experts, and there is no credible evidence against this claim (in other words, Anthropic is probably correct) 2) It is imposs…

> If #2 was false, surely some other LLM lab would have done it by now.

This is a logical flaw. LLM that is immune to jailbreak _could_ exist, but not yet, or maybe nobody talks about it. Yes there's a market, but all of these AI boom is too recent to make any claims.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#538
post #521

There is so much hot air and guff around AI, so please if you don't believe me verify yourself, but GLM 5.2 is "good enough" to replace Claude Code / Codex. No it's not frontier, but it's beyond that point that Opus 4.5 hit where people started to really depend on Claude Code around last November time. It's also a fraction of the cost of a Claude Code subscription especially when you account for how high the usage li…

It seems more like the Chinese companies ar playing the dirty game, distilling through bot accounts, not letting real competition across their firewall.

So you are believing Anthropic's claim here, and it's not as if Anthropic didn't steal the data to train the model in the first place. I think the original sin doesn't give them any ability to complain.

- https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/sep/05/anthropic...

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#539

There's two basic kinds of distillation: 1) the massive [and dumb] method where you ask a question and use the answer as reinforcement (Black Box), and 2) more targeted distillation where you use one model to directly inform/train/guide another model (RLAIF). The latter is basically fine-tuning the model with direction from another model. Thousands of businesses do this every day to fine-tune. This is almost certainl…

The compute deficit of Chinese Ai companies is real, and it IS THE ONLY competitive advantage that Western companies have. The only way the U.S. keeps that edge is to prevent distillation. The only way Chinese companies can make up for the deficit in compute is to distill. There innovation in great supply on every side of the Ocean. Its about the chips. And in terms of national security, for the U.S., and for China,…

> The only way the U.S. keeps that edge is to prevent distillation.

For how long ? year ? how long till model that is year behind will be fine for 90%+ use cases ?

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#540
post #534

I'll just leave it here: "Anthropic's downloading of over seven million books from pirate sites like LibGen constituted infringement, the judge ruled, rejecting Anthropic's "research purpose" defense: "You can't just bless yourself by saying I have a research purpose and, therefore, go and take any textbook you want." https://www.joneswalker.com/en/insights/blogs/ai-law-blog/wh...

Yet they did not need to destroy the models which were trained with them?
Post reply on HN