Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

reuters.com

501–510 of 1001 posts

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#501

The hypocrisy of Anthropic complaining about "illicitly extracting its Claude AI model capabilities" and supporting the White House's accusation of China "stealing U.S. AI labs' intellectual property on an industrial scale" is hilarious. Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, et al trained their models by ignoring the rights of copyright holders when harvesting whatever content they could. Now one of them is crying fo…

What's yours is mine, and what's mine is still mine.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#502
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you need macbooks? Just rent servers from any hosting provider.

Not going to work for very long or at any scale coming from datacenter/hosting provider IPs. Google "residential proxies for sale" for the tip of an iceberg of how they snowshoe the traffic.

There are lots of botnets providing home IPs.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#505

This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. I also learnt that Anthropic should get better at what they do if they want to compete. If not, somebody else will win. Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

China aren't offering a cheaper solution. They are subsidizing an existing one (which is already subsidized) in order to gain foothold. The difference is that in the US subsidies come from VC, while OP implies subsidies come from the AI labs that buy the training data (which may as well also be VC backed, so just one extra hop). This isn't "the market working as intended", this is an exhaustion fight to the bottom wh…

> This isn't "the market working as intended", this is an exhaustion fight to the bottom where the one with most money gets to stay in the market.

That's, uh, pretty much exactly how oligopolistic markets function.

> I find it hard to compare that with a free market.

Well, to have free market you need to remove as much barriers to enter the market as possible. Huge capital investments required for entry and intellectual property laws are two examples of such barriers. Subsidies kinda supposed to help alleviate the first one.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#506
post #123

This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. I also learnt that Anthropic should get better at what they do if they want to compete. If not, somebody else will win. Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

It never did. In debt the first 5000 years Geaeber makes the case that pure “free market” trade has never really existed in “the west”. The closest to this ideal that’s ever happened was during the Islamic golden age enabled by religious prescriptions against usury.

Usury (i.e. taking interest) sounds like free market to me. If you don't like my interest rates, borrow somewhere else.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#508
post #486
post #472

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stupid question: I was under the impression that these models were trained on PB of data. Surely the amount of questions/response they can extract from querying a bigger model (Claude) is fairly modest. How is it not a drop vs the training dataset?

This might be like an observational study vs a study with a control?

From what I understand, at this point, the main value of stronger model outputs is simply to bootstrap reasoning behavior during the RL post-training phase. It gets you past the “cold start” problem with RL, after which the outputs aren’t needed anymore. From then on, it’s hill climbing and that requires environments for the model to interact with get rewards from.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#510

Here's what is happening: Chinese resellers are offering Claude tokens at 70-90% below official Anthropic API prices. They achieve this by reselling capacity from pooled Claude Max accounts, payments fraud, and also reselling the model output & reasoning chains to various Chinese labs. They are subsidizing model access in exchange for user logs and reasoning traces, which they then sell as training data, allowing the…

It's fucking laughable to see people complain about what they did and still do. Using illicitly extracted data? That's all main LLM playbook. Onslaught of bots? Ask where the bots almost DOSing most internet sites for the last couple years come from.

As some people would say: Cheh

Post reply on HN