Live data from Hacker News

Ending respiratory infections

blog.interceptfund.com

21–30 of 146 posts

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#21

> Healthy people spend roughly 15-25 days each year—about 5% of their lives—sick with respiratory infections like the common cold and influenza This seems completely unbelievable to me. Totally outside of my personal, professional, and family experience.

I would love to move to whatever planet you're living on. To me the estimate seems low.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#22

I'd be interested to see more concerted research into contagious/self-replicable vaccines that are self-replicating and spreadable to a wider swath of people. That seems like a step forward in public health prevention for seasonal illnesses that we have well-engineered and safe vaccines for. I understand the bar for deployment would need to be high to ensure that side effects are even rare compared to typical volunta…

Self-replicating vaccines? We already have those. They're called diseases.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#23
> Why haven’t we already seen the same kind of transformation with respiratory viruses?

Because it’s a lot easier to control the supply of a material that has to be actively transported into people’s houses for them to use? I struggle to take them seriously when I didn’t see this basic and fundamental difference even mentioned.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#24
It's sad we're resorting to philanthropy to solve problems like this. $500M is chump change.

NASA spent something like $300B in today's money on the Apollo program, and Artemis has exceeded $90B already.

I'm much more keen on never getting sick than prepping for Mars.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#25
Can it be dangerous to use uv as it can cause mutations in pathogens potentially making them evolve even faster?

I assume the kind of uv used must be fatal, but is there a chance that a tiny percentage makes it?

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#26
post #24

It's sad we're resorting to philanthropy to solve problems like this. $500M is chump change. NASA spent something like $300B in today's money on the Apollo program, and Artemis has exceeded $90B already. I'm much more keen on never getting sick than prepping for Mars.

It’s 500m spend without guaranteed success.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#27
post #25

Can it be dangerous to use uv as it can cause mutations in pathogens potentially making them evolve even faster? I assume the kind of uv used must be fatal, but is there a chance that a tiny percentage makes it?

Sunlight is the biggest UV source and at the scales we’re talking, manmade disinfectants would not register

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#28
post #24

It's sad we're resorting to philanthropy to solve problems like this. $500M is chump change. NASA spent something like $300B in today's money on the Apollo program, and Artemis has exceeded $90B already. I'm much more keen on never getting sick than prepping for Mars.

The Iran war is going to cost us at least $200 billion dollars and you’re over here complaining about NASA spending?

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#29
post #24

It's sad we're resorting to philanthropy to solve problems like this. $500M is chump change. NASA spent something like $300B in today's money on the Apollo program, and Artemis has exceeded $90B already. I'm much more keen on never getting sick than prepping for Mars.

It’s 500m spend without guaranteed success.

Yeah, so was building moon rockets.

Re: Ending respiratory infections

#30
While I think it’s a noble idea I think much more could be achieved with much smaller amounts of money. Actually zero. Regulate sugar, introduce a HIGH sugar tax. Introduce higher nicotine and alcohol tax. Introduce stricter environmental controls for poisonous materials and water and air pollution. All these things cost essentially zero to implement, they even bring in money and all of them are credible ways to significantly reduce health problems world wide. But eh, I’m not part of a lobbying organisation, so what do I know.
Post reply on HN