Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

reuters.com

191–200 of 1001 posts

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if that's a real quote from Gates, but I do know it was in Pirates of Silicon Valley.

Seems legit: https://www.folklore.org/A_Rich_Neighbor_Named_Xerox.html

Neat, so the scene in the movie was pretty close to reality then!

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#192

Here's what is happening: Chinese resellers are offering Claude tokens at 70-90% below official Anthropic API prices. They achieve this by reselling capacity from pooled Claude Max accounts, payments fraud, and also reselling the model output & reasoning chains to various Chinese labs. They are subsidizing model access in exchange for user logs and reasoning traces, which they then sell as training data, allowing the…

Im ok with this! Is there a site that list all these resellers, or better, a openrouter-like for these resellers?

They're called 中转站 (transfer stations/proxies). They can be a bit tricky to find on your own, so I'd suggest asking your preferred AI to search in Mandarin for you. I linked a larger operator in the parent comment, or have a look at https://hvoy.ai/ which lists a ton. You can also find many on Funpay, which may be easier to use.

This is one seller I found, they're reselling "real Max 20x subscription accounts", at ~97% below official API prices https://funpay.com/en/lots/offer?id=70812310

Note that whoever you buy from will be able to read all your tokens, so don’t use it for anything confidential/financial.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#193
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you need macbooks? Just rent servers from any hosting provider.

Not going to work for very long or at any scale coming from datacenter/hosting provider IPs. Google "residential proxies for sale" for the tip of an iceberg of how they snowshoe the traffic.

I use my Codex and Claude Code subs on like 4-6 different servers, ranging from AWS to Vultr to Linode etc.

That’s a major and legitimate use case for developers, Anthropic can’t just block data center/hosting IPs because their actual customers use them on data center/hosting IPs.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#194

This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. I also learnt that Anthropic should get better at what they do if they want to compete. If not, somebody else will win. Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

> Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

When it comes to favorite companies of the tech communities, it's almost always "Rules for thee, but not for me"

The standard stance is "they can do no wrong and they are absolutely perfect". I mean, look at any thread with anything about Apple in it.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#195
post #140

This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. I also learnt that Anthropic should get better at what they do if they want to compete. If not, somebody else will win. Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

>This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. Yeah, like all those Chinese bootleggers selling DVDs for a few dollars rather than $20. Free market! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48664814

This is also a good thing fwiw.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#196
post #140

This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. I also learnt that Anthropic should get better at what they do if they want to compete. If not, somebody else will win. Or does this not apply to huge US corporations any more?

>This is great for competition! Chinese vendors offering a cheaper solution = what economics told me the free market was all about. Yeah, like all those Chinese bootleggers selling DVDs for a few dollars rather than $20. Free market! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48664814

Bootlegging is copyright theft.

Is Claude output copyrighted?

If anything, a tremendous amount of Claude’s input is copyrighted.

If there’s any bootlegging going on it’s Anthropic that’s doing the bootlegging but having mirrored the video etc sufficiently to beat copyright law.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#197
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If Anthropic is selling a dollar for less than a dollar, they are running a business that doesn't make sense. That's what jeopardizes Claude Max, not this.

Plenty of things are intentionally run at a loss (for years!) to gain market share and quantity of ongoing recurring users, or with expectation of ROI later on. Multiple generations of the Xbox hardware have been sold at a loss with the expectation that customers will purchase 300, 400, 500 dollars worth of games, which are very high margin, over the lifespan they own the system.

In international trade, isn’t this called dumping which gets major political pushback?

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The resellers route requests via one of thousands of Claude Max 5x accounts. When an account reaches its usage limit, they automatically switch to another account.

Why would they use Max 5x instead of Max 20x, which is cheaper relatively speaking?

Don’t trust my experiences as fact since it’s a bit opaque, but I believe 20x only offers 4x the 5hr session limits. The weekly limit is still 2x, which is the same as the price increase.

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> what economics told me the free market was all about. Don't complain when US starts to play by the same rules China has been using for decades.

How do you think the major AI companies trained there model? Pirated books and anything that could be torrented and scraped of the web.

they were being sarcastic

Re: Anthropic says Alibaba illicitly extracted Claude AI model capabilities

#200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple gave Xerox the right to buy $1 million of pre-IPO stock before the meeting took place.

Glad you pointed this out. I believe the sequence was that Jobs himself got a shorter demo during his first visit with no prior arrangements. He then negotiated bringing back a group of his key people to get a more in depth demo and that included the stock deal. When Apple was accused of 'ripping off' PARC, Steve didn't seem keen to bring up this rather salient point. I suspect it may have been a combination of wanti…

Lisa and early MacOS are tremendously different in their details than the Alto operating system. While there was clearly a transfer of inspiration, Apple engineers like Bill Atkinson made countless small and large innovations to simplify the Xerox GUI model and improve its usability based on extensive in-house R&D and user testing (and in some cases implement features that the Apple team presumed Xerox had but actually didn't exist on the Alto). It is simply ahistoric to build narratives around Apple stealing Xerox ideas wholesale.

For more details on Apple's early UI evolution, Atkinson kept polaroids of a variety of prototypes and mockups: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qg0mHFcB510

Post reply on HN