Live data from Hacker News

The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

nytimes.com

51–60 of 816 posts

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#52
At the same time avoidance systems have become much better on those large new cars… so would it have even worse had collision avoidance not come into being?

Also interesting that often people tend to imagine F-150s, Silverados ,etc., but if you see what people drive they are large Bentzs, Toyotas and of course Suburbans and F-150s. But everyone is building them not just American manufacturers.

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#56
post #51

there’s another thing that started to get quite popular in the late 2000s… smartphones

that's called a hypothesis. now go author a study to test it, like the study being reported on. hypotheses without evidence don't stand up to hypotheses that have been tested.

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#57
post #51

there’s another thing that started to get quite popular in the late 2000s… smartphones

Then surely Europe shares that trends and shows growth in pedestrian death.

But that isn't the case at all, maybe Europeans are immune to smartphones: https://road-safety.transport.ec.europa.eu/document/download...

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#58
post #54
post #51

there’s another thing that started to get quite popular in the late 2000s… smartphones

Almost like we need a study to figure out what the actual cause is. Oh, that's what the article is about, the study.

Per tfa vehicle size “ represents about 10 percent of the recent increase in pedestrian deaths” so the title is really a distraction from the (likely) root cause that GP brings up.

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#59
WA state recently passed a law about e-bikes/e-motorcycles to deal with the issue of younger teens on these kinda moped-style e-bikes going very fast around town (and often riding quite recklessly).

The law is reasonable, but it strikes me what a double standard there is for biking vs driving. For biking, there's a danger that's noticed, and we quickly pass a law that straight up bans that type of bike for those riders.

Meanwhile, everyone knows that these giant trucks and SUVs are killing people, but we do basically nothing. Even on the off chance that we passed a law about them, existing vehicles would certainly be grandfathered in, we would never outright ban current vehicles/motorists. If we banned existing SUVs and trucks, millions of people would be screaming bloody murder about their right to drive pedestrian-killing cars.

Re: The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs

#60
post #52

At the same time avoidance systems have become much better on those large new cars… so would it have even worse had collision avoidance not come into being? Also interesting that often people tend to imagine F-150s, Silverados ,etc., but if you see what people drive they are large Bentzs, Toyotas and of course Suburbans and F-150s. But everyone is building them not just American manufacturers.

> But everyone is building them not just American manufacturers

But for, and driven by, the American market.

I would hazard a guess that Silverados sold outside of US, Canada, Mexico and Australia can fit in a single parking lot.

Post reply on HN