Live data from Hacker News

AI's Affordability Crisis

blog.dshr.org

121–130 of 436 posts

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Assuming the analysis is right, and most (or all) of these AI companies will default on their debts, what consequences might that have?

>what consequences might that have? All depends on who is holding the bag, and how big the bag is.

Probably 401 (k) plans for the most part.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#122
post #73

The math doesn’t add up and the wheels are starting to come off the bus. The conversation in a lot of wealth management offices has shifted dramatically in the last few month from “how do I get in on this AI thing?” to “how do I protect my assets when this AI stuff blows up.” There’s little question now if this will all implode, just when and who’s going to lose their shirt and be left without chairs when the music s…

Assuming the analysis is right, and most (or all) of these AI companies will default on their debts, what consequences might that have?

If that happens the AI companies will first try to negotiate with their creditors and after that likely declare bankruptcy with the creditors taking over what’s left of the assets. Shareholders will be wiped out and employees will be left with nothing. Various franken-companies will emerge from the bankruptcy ashes and the world will move on with AI sans the present irrational exuberance.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#123
post #27

My take is that Anthropic and OpenAI simply are NOT competing on price. 2 big players are often not enough to create tension on price. Chinese models and open model providers are, indeed, competing on price, and the difference shows.

Chinese models are dropping in price thanks to ridiculous levels of state subsidy where companies are forced into aggressive price wars to survive and grab market share. I am guessing this will also blow up sometime next year or in 2029 at the maximum. Btw, some Chinese corporates have already seen this and increased their price. Zhipu AI & Tencent for example. Alibaba, Baidu, and Tencent also announced multiple pric…

This is in contrast to American models which receive _ridiculous_ levels of private subsidy.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#124
I know a lot of level-headed engineers here may not side with me, but I say let the companies who abandoned their people at the drop of a hat, with CEOs who waved their flag around on social media, proudly declaring how they'd now run their companies with 75% fewer employees wither and die. If I had been let go, there's no way I'd go back to a company like that, and there should be a black list of CEOs who acted this way established and kept public. These CEOs are not holistic thinkers, and are too susceptible to mass hysteria and too irresponsible to real people and their lives to be trusted with the vision for any company ever again.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Assuming the analysis is right, and most (or all) of these AI companies will default on their debts, what consequences might that have?

If that happens the AI companies will first try to negotiate with their creditors and after that likely declare bankruptcy with the creditors taking over what’s left of the assets. Shareholders will be wiped out and employees will be left with nothing. Various franken-companies will emerge from the bankruptcy ashes and the world will move on with AI sans the present irrational exuberance.

And then the US government will say that these company's futures are in the national interest, and they will be bailed out with taxpayer dollars.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#126

I think the biggest problem is not necessarily the cost to develop & serve the models, but how quickly user behavior changed with token based pricing. I know a lot of people at companies where the marching orders changed on a dime end of Q1/start of Q2. These are shops that were fully on the "use AI or die (because we will fire you)" train. Now there's monitoring, reporting, alerting not just on overall cost but on "…

I can second this. Our company and department was all-in on AI. And since the token-based pricing came in, we got an email from IT that tried to explain that most developers don't know how to choose models and that the cheap models should be good enough for most of our work ..

Have they built an internal ai enablement team?

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#127
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Microsoft adding Deepseek support I believe this hasn't been confirmed yet but I think it speaks to a bigger problem for the AI companies which is, if you give capable developers a good reasoning LLM, they can make it work like it was a really expensive model. I believe we are 100% at the stage of good enough for the vast majority of tech companines. Fable and others will be more valuable for non-traditional tech c…

If hardware becomes the moat, the US frontier labs are screwed. We have AWS, Azure, GCP. All three have or are making inference silicon. LLMs become just another service in the public cloud's large service catalog, and open weight wins. Which makes sense to me. Selling a chatbot interface/model access to the general public was never going to be a viable long term play. You still need developers to wrap the models int…

The big thing is, the western world has moved so much of the manufacturing to China and think a lot of people will not forgive Samsung and others, so I can see China owning a good portion of the supply chain.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#128
post #80

The coming AI enshittification is going to be epic. For those of us who have been on the web for more than five minutes, we can see this a mile away. If you think search ads are annoying, pre-roll YouTube ads are annoying, streaming ads are annoying, or basically ads-on-any-screen-anywhere-at-any-time are annoying, just wait until every stupid thing is powered by AI and is subtly trying to manipulate you to buy/watch…

Jeopardizing a $200/month subscription in return for $1/month in ad revenue seems insane. Using ads on a $20/month subscription to entice you into a $200/month one, OTOH...

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Frontier models may eventually achieve super-intelligence but super-intelligence isn't necessary for most practical day-to-day programming I think you forgot what super-intelligence means…

tbh, not sure i ever understood it

A superintelligence is one that exceeds human intelligence in all areas. Which roughly translates to learning, adapting, and performing more quickly and efficiently than even the best humans. This is closely related to "the singularity", which is when technological growth becomes uncontrollable by humanity.

Re: AI's Affordability Crisis

#130
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I.e., the demand for programming tokens turns out to be quite elastic.

I would imagine it only gets worse in the face of good-enough open/chinese/local models too right? Microsoft adding Deepseek support already as I recall? That is - for any definition of "they are behind X months" then eventually they get to the point Claude was in January when the world freaked out, but at 1/10th the cost. A lot of firms are going to mandate that is good enough for their developers.

Yup, we are in the process of getting access to US hosted Chinese models. I've been petitioning Google and our rep, we will see but I suspect they will cave eventually. Gemini sucks and if they don't sell what their customers want, we go shopping around.
Post reply on HN