Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

purl.ly

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#11
post #8

Interesting choice to use a Libyan domain for a service like this.

How is using a Libyan domain interesting here? Bit.ly is doing it.

Who? Bitly.com?

Perhaps Libya is as reliable as anywhere else in the world - it's all a matter of perspective. Ask The Pirate Bay guys how confident they would be using a .com. Still, the idea of putting a service that offers 'permanence' on a domain so far out of reach seems like a bad idea to me.

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#13

Looks like not many people are actually using it: http://purl.ly/purl/index

It launched with this Show HN...

Fair enough, I'm just surprised there's so few links. Looks like most people that have seen it haven't even tried it...

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#14
post #10

This is a good idea in theory, but not if in form of a company. This would require something like a consortium where Google, Microsoft, Twitter, Facebook, ... and a few more federates to create a service paying for the bill and with the intention to take it up for the future as long as possible.

Plus there's already a service that does the same thing, is free, and is heavily relied upon, WebCite.

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#15
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is using a Libyan domain interesting here? Bit.ly is doing it.

Who? Bitly.com? Perhaps Libya is as reliable as anywhere else in the world - it's all a matter of perspective. Ask The Pirate Bay guys how confident they would be using a .com. Still, the idea of putting a service that offers 'permanence' on a domain so far out of reach seems like a bad idea to me.

The nameservers themselves are here in the us, which will hopefully help. But you have a good point.

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#19
How do you resolve offering a permanent URL for something whilst also complying with DMCA takedowns for copyright materials when the end service may have removed the content but you continue to publish it?

Re: Show HN: A Url Permanence Service

#20
I don't like the redirect page, it's a large and heavy page with a forced delay and what looks like placeholders for a ton of ads.

It might be better packaged as something blogs and forums can automagically implement for a fee instead of trying to make money off ads.

Post reply on HN