Live data from Hacker News

VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

birminghammail.co.uk

61–70 of 400 posts

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#61

Just moved back to the UK after many years away, and it's creepy here. Doing the elderly under terror legislation, some crazy kangaroo court antics, a frankly sinister approach to "online safety". VPNs? The even more concerning thing is that we've got a far right party that have been leading in the polls for most of the last year. This is a very dangerous situation.

[deleted]

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#62

At least we get to raise the next generation of IT geeks because they'll have to understand a bunch of networking basics to watch porn, and might get hooked on it. (on IT)

Israel will be making kill on this, they will unleash their free VPNs to the young people like they did to Iran. UK national security will be like Suisse cheese

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#63
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> these big companies need to self police It's not possible to prevent a person (of any age) from reaching a specific website if they are determined enough. Full stop.

> It's not possible to prevent a person (of any age) from reaching a specific website if they are determined enough. Full stop. right, and that reveals the absurdity of this "age gate", doesn't it? because I am sure giving every UK national their very own unicorn would also poll very well but that doesn't mean that's what a functional democracy should be prioritizing just because a majority of the public supports bec…

It’s not possible to prevent these same children from getting alcohol or drugs either but we certainly don’t permit it.

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#64
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> big companies need to self police and if a child can reach their service they have to pay the child like lets say GBP 10k per instance? HIPAA has been super effective this way. As we all know, American companies don’t give two shits about user privacy or even security. But wave the HIPAA flag and everyone starts caring real hard and taking extremely cumbersome steps to comply with patient privacy. Very simple: Each…

I agree the threat is there but I've never seen anyone actually punished for HIPAA violations and my data have been involved in several hospital and insurance breaches.

There's not even a test for HIPAA compliance, so you can't legally prove you were ever compliant in the first place, other than you did what you thought was right. People love to use the term "HIPAA-compliant" but it's technically not a thing.

From my understanding, HIPAA mostly just says that you need to have policies in place for various things, such as rotating passwords or encrypting data, but it doesn't go into explicit detail about what all must be IN those policies, or how you enforce them.

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#65

> the main thing that we've done is we've commissioned additional research on this because I've not been happy with the evidence. Ah, yes, the existing research doesn't agree with our biases, so let's fund new "research" that does.

Obviously Labour has been "lobbied" and now have to deliver this for whoever wants this. It's pathetic how they use sobbing families to push it through, similar tactic like before Iraq invasion. same players behind the scenes.

This is pretty much it. Bought and paid for, or hand forced by intelligence powers operating beyond ordinary voter politics

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Obviously Labour has been "lobbied" and now have to deliver this for whoever wants this. It's pathetic how they use sobbing families to push it through, similar tactic like before Iraq invasion. same players behind the scenes.

Conspiracy theory^ This is happening worldwide: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_age_verification_laws_b...

The fact that it's coordinated in all "Western" countries show it's a real conspiracy, not just a theory.

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#69
post #45

I've been using a VPN in the UK on my laptop and phone exclusively for 20 years, and the state has been working with ISPs to make "connection records" for most of that time. On mobile a VPN isn't always effective in avoid geoblocks. Some apps are able to determine I'm in the UK and still ask for ID - reddit is one for example, if you stumble on to an adult subreddit. Using the web interface avoids this. The UK has al…

> On mobile VPN isn't always effective in avoid geoblocks. Some apps are able to determine I'm in the UK and still ask for ID - reddit is one for example, if you stumble on to an adult subreddit.

I've never had this issue (using Private Internet Access on iOS).

Re: VPN ban update for UK households as government looks at 'age-gate'

#70
Some context - Birmingham Mail is one of dozens of clickbait-driven publications owned by Reach plc.

They're not a high quality source of news - they've more than decimated their journalism staff and replaced them with 'content' staff who are performance monitored on the number of clicks their articles generate.

Content is syndicated in different accents across their range of papers from the national papers, The Mirror and The Daily Express down into a large number of notionally 'local' outlets.

So, take it with a pinch of salt.

Post reply on HN