Live data from Hacker News

Want your images back? That'll be $5

lutr.dev

11–20 of 286 posts

Re: Want your images back? That'll be $5

#14
post #9

Just do a GDPR request and get all the data they have on you for free. I’m pretty sure they would have to give you your photos as part of that.

Are photos considered PII?

Not in general, but depending on what’s on them maybe. A profile picture showing my face definitely is.

But I’m also not sure that they only have to give you PII.

Re: Want your images back? That'll be $5

#15
post #9

Just do a GDPR request and get all the data they have on you for free. I’m pretty sure they would have to give you your photos as part of that.

Are photos considered PII?

PII is a US-specific concept that has little relevance to the GDPR. So I wouldn’t say for sure that they have to give those photos to you but it wouldn’t be as simple as “not PII”.

Re: Want your images back? That'll be $5

#16
post #6

Just do a GDPR request and get all the data they have on you for free. I’m pretty sure they would have to give you your photos as part of that.

Aren't they only required to delete the data on request? They don't have to actually provide it back to you

IANAL.

Article 15 says you have the right to request the data and they must provide it to you.

Article 20 says you have the right to get your photos back in a machine readable format.

Sadly, this only applies to those in the EU. Americans can keep taking it, which makes sense as it's an American company that's giving it. Sigh.

Re: Want your images back? That'll be $5

#18
I have received the email that my photobucket account is going to be deleted, so I've logged in after who knows how many years and got offered the same thing, to subscribe. Instead I've went to close the account and in the process (or somewhere else, don't remember exactly) there was an option to first download all the data which I've used and got the images back (there were just a few as I haven't used the service really), then I've closed the account. There was no need to subscribe.
Post reply on HN