Live data from Hacker News

AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 52 posts

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#31
If we believe the people selling AI, keeping up your skills at code is like keeping your expertise at wooden wheel making during the time of the automobile. We have to ask ourselves if they’re right or not.

I think they’re wrong, but also that even if they were right I wouldn’t give money to some assholes that stole every book, movie, piece of art, and published line of code. To me it seems clear that a company “forcing you to use AI because efficiency” is exactly the same as “welcome our new external team you’ll be interfacing with! They’ll write that pesky code.” Fuck that, I’d bail, I can read the writing on the wall.

Also these AI data center pricks want to drink up all the water and make us compete on our power bills with Google and Microsoft. That sucks. They suck.

You can watch your coworkers de-skill themselves in real time. Why would you not want that? Less competition - if you think it’s still a valuable skill.

I do.

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#32
I sometimes have claude or the coding-agent quiz me, Socratic style.

It persists in asking questions at deeper levels until you arrive at the answer yourself. This forces you to think hard about a problem, and this effort helps with understanding, learning and retention. Of course I made a Socratic-quiz skill for this, to use with any coding agent or similar:

https://pchalasani.github.io/claude-code-tools/plugins-detai...

For example I’ve used this to better understand counter-intuitive things about diabetes/insulin, dopamine and motivation, catching up with a codebase, Claude’s implementations, etc (to combat so-called cognitive debt).

Strong LLMs are surprisingly good at this type of quizzing, they display a semblance of “theory of mind”.

[Edited - link fixed]

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#35

I sometimes have claude or the coding-agent quiz me, Socratic style. It persists in asking questions at deeper levels until you arrive at the answer yourself. This forces you to think hard about a problem, and this effort helps with understanding, learning and retention. Of course I made a Socratic-quiz skill for this, to use with any coding agent or similar: https://pchalasani.github.io/claude-code-tools/plugins-det…

The URL returns a 404...

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#36

I sometimes have claude or the coding-agent quiz me, Socratic style. It persists in asking questions at deeper levels until you arrive at the answer yourself. This forces you to think hard about a problem, and this effort helps with understanding, learning and retention. Of course I made a Socratic-quiz skill for this, to use with any coding agent or similar: https://pchalasani.github.io/claude-code-tools/plugins-det…

The URL returns a 404...

Thanks, not sure what went wrong, but fixed it now

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They can be easily replaced. I suspect we are just engaging in a form of self deception by thinking these choices we make are more than arbitrary decisions driven by nothing but our taste...

Often times I find agreeing to the stack the model suggests is the right option. It’s probably most trained on that.

I suppose one would have to work in a very specific novel and niche area to go against the grain and chose stacks that are not chosen by majority.

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

prompting is not a skill. prompt engineering, harness engineering watever are copes.

A very intentional line in my CLAUDE/AGENTS is to act as the Principle Engineer and to explain architectural decisions along the way. I'm not about blindly generating the outcome. I'm reviewing decisions, asking deep questions, performing research and basically taking a college-level course in a specific topic with every big project I deliver.

I told mine to code as if it is the love child of Fabrice Bellard and Jonn Carmack.

Doesn’t seem to be working though.

Re: AskHN:How do you handle skill atrophy from using coding agents?

#40

I sometimes have claude or the coding-agent quiz me, Socratic style. It persists in asking questions at deeper levels until you arrive at the answer yourself. This forces you to think hard about a problem, and this effort helps with understanding, learning and retention. Of course I made a Socratic-quiz skill for this, to use with any coding agent or similar: https://pchalasani.github.io/claude-code-tools/plugins-det…

This is looking interesting, thank you for sharing.
Post reply on HN