Live data from Hacker News

Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

richardosgood.com

101–110 of 396 posts

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This was my thought as well. I think the workaround is to have the device present itself as a captive portal type of thing, like you might encounter at a Starbucks, so that when the user is prompted to "Sign In" they immediately find the dead drop. However I haven't actually played with this and don't know if that would work, or if the network would require DNS to function properly.

That's exactly what this project attempts to do. It acts as a captive portal.

Oh, excellent. I didn't catch that in the portions I skimmed.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#102
post #92
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Note that I don't necessarily agree with the subject matter of these titles Y'know, there's really only one reason to be coy about whether you agree with Neo-Nazi propaganda.

Someone named tinfoilhatter replied but that's gone now. Not one to let a response go to waste: Well. I seem to have triggered something. > Ah yes, because the only people that have ever spread propaganda are Neo-Nazis Not something I ever said or implied. > and we should only ever learn about the sanitized and approved version of history from our Robert Maxwell (Ghislane Maxwell's Mossad agent father / McGraw Hill c…

[flagged]

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"For once"? That's a significant impugnment of the honesty of a person you know nothing about. "Banned books" is the colloquial term for these books, even if it's not as accurate as you'd personally prefer. Next thing you'll be complaining you bit into an Apple and got computer instead of fruit.

> "Banned books" is the colloquial term for these books Yes, many people are either unaware of, or willing participants in, this lie. That doesn't make it any less of a lie.

It's not a lie. Some entity somewhere banned them. It's vague, not inaccurate.

You're just pissy because they aren't using your personal favorite parameters around "banned" for "by whom" and "for whom". You're pretending your opinion is fact and therefore anyone who disagrees must be a liar.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> As if Neo-Nazis were and are the only people capable of authoring propaganda Of course they aren't. But that's no argument for distributing it.

No, the argument for distributing it would be that other propaganda is widely distributed without question, so if one wants to arrive at anything even close to an objective account of what transpired during that time in history, all propaganda should be examined and learned about. The truth usually lies somewhere in the middle, and we certainly aren't getting to it by blindly accepting one narrative over another.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#105
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Note that I don't necessarily agree with the subject matter of these titles Y'know, there's really only one reason to be coy about whether you agree with Neo-Nazi propaganda.

[flagged]

> You don't have to agree with Neo-Nazi propaganda to acknowledge that what we are taught about WWII and Weimar Germany in school, isn't the truth either.

Go on then.

Say what you mean.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#106
post #89
post #34

“As the Americans learned so painfully in Earth’s final century, free flow of information is the only safeguard against tyranny. The once-chained people whose leaders at last lose their grip on information flow will soon burst with freedom and vitality, but the free nation gradually constricting its grip on public discourse has begun its rapid slide into despotism. Beware of he who would deny you access to informatio…

The "information wants to be free" discourse of just under 30 years ago feels so charmingly naive now that we've seen how lies are also information and can travel even better using the same flow.

Truly something we still have to figure out. Attention budget is real and things can get buried. The really big problem of our time.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#107
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is not disingenuous, maybe a little loose on the 'meaning', but your definition is rather narrow. The Color Purple has been challenged many times in order to be removed from public library circulation and public school curriculums. Annie on my Mind was banned from the Kansas Public School system and subject to book burnings at the federal courthouse. The removal of the book (ban?) was overturned by the court. Ther…

It's rather subjective, though, no? Having been in prison, I can tell you that being a Blood and having "certain books" in your locker is a "smash on sight" offense. The same could be said for the Aryan Brotherhood/Circle, and I'm sure for many other gangs. There's a difference between "this one small group: local oklahoma school district/aryan brotherhood/catholic church" decided they don't like a book and the gover…

It is subjective. I believe the application or suggestion here is if you are in a community that denies people under 18 the right to have access to certain books over philosophical differences, you can create a book server and give them access to books. If you live in a state, or institution in your example, that will legally punish you or worse for selling or owning a book, you can create a book server. The two are not different really, the systems/people that are limiting the access to literature and information through varying means of enforcement are trying to achieve the same ends, state enforced censorship and control.

In the article example, to deny this because of a technically or the degree of legal enforcement is foolish since it is rebelling against the act of banning books, the process of banning, which doesn't occur out of thin air, it is an evolution of acts. It is not an absolute and one doesn't have to wait until there is a legally defined ban to start the protest. That would be ridiculous as it would be too late.

I don't think the project is trying to make the Banned Library of Congress either, anyone could put whatever books they want on their server. It is suggesting civil disobedience by circumventing oppression through censorship with creativity, which is awesome.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#108
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> You don't have to agree with Neo-Nazi propaganda to acknowledge that what we are taught about WWII and Weimar Germany in school, isn't the truth either. Go on then. Say what you mean.

I just said what I meant - what we are taught about WWII and Weimar Germany in school isn't anything approaching the truth. For example: https://www.archives.gov/research/foreign-policy/katyn-massa...

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#109
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> You don't have to agree with Neo-Nazi propaganda to acknowledge that what we are taught about WWII and Weimar Germany in school, isn't the truth either. Go on then. Say what you mean.

I just said what I meant - what we are taught about WWII and Weimar Germany in school isn't anything approaching the truth. For example: https://www.archives.gov/research/foreign-policy/katyn-massa...

I don’t know what school you went to, but mine covered war crimes committed by the Allies plenty.

That doesn’t mean Nazi Germany wasn’t utterly disgusting though.

Re: Banned book library in a wi-fi smart light bulb

#110
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

when it's banned by the federal government.

So if a book is banned by a widespread movement of extremists taking control of local governing bodies and the federal government is not involved, that's okay then?

I am absolutely dumbfounded that this seems to be ok to some people.
Post reply on HN