Live data from Hacker News

A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

cnn.com

121–130 of 429 posts

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#121

[flagged]

Your faith stopped the climate change, congratulations! And all that we needed was a pure soul to wake up the princess of snow!

Ehm... nope. Another yearly record of heat, directly to the sink. Damned real world.

At this moment trolling people that for some reason still keeps playing the "virtuous climate denial" card is not even funny.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Western nations reducing will DO nothing - it is too small a fraction of greenhouse emissions. The large fraction is coming form india and china. And they do not have electric everything. they don't even have running water in most places.

Your view is outdated. China is building renewable power generation at an extremely high rate, and also exporting cheap solar panels worldwide. China has a higher share of electric vehicles in cities than most of Europe and America does. It appears their emissions are now starting to go down as a result, although the economy keeps growing. India still has a long way to go, but China is doing the right things. Same ca…

>Same can't be said about USA under current administration.

The reason half the population won't take climate alarmists seriously are statements like this.

Saying the West, generally, or the US, specifically "aren't doing anything" is ridiculous.

https://ourworldindata.org/profile/co2/united-states

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#123
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed. You aren't going to convince people in India that their children should stay poor when there is an option to uplift them. That's an extra billion people of energy and material needs, all by itself.

The question is whether you use solar PV or build more coal plants to supply them. The latter makes people sicker, but more dependent on the government, so you can guess which one gets the tax breaks and which one gets tariffs and international politics to make it more expensive to acquire.

Coal technology is cheap and wide spread. PV technology is not, yet.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#124
post #92
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A carbon tax would change behavior in short order. The challenge is introducing then maintaining it; people can always vote it out. I think left-leaning jurisdictions should definitely give it a try.

the challenge in carbon tax isn't the people who vote it out, it's the people who never vote it in in the country next door (or on the other side of the world, it hardly matters)

That's not a challenge; passing it in one place gives people in others an example to point to. Nobody wants to tax themselves while others don't.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#125
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you walk in the middle of a highway then you "could" be hit by a truck. "Might" be left at the side of the road as a hit-and-run. Don't take it seriously though; go walk on that highway like it's yours.

You act as if reacting to global warming is cost-free. It would have a drastic impact on the economy and people's standard of living, especially in the 3rd world.

You act as if NOT reacting to global warming is cost-free. It WILL have a drastic impact on the economy and people's standard of living, especially in the 3rd world.

Yes I literally copied your comment, added a single word and modified another; it's that easy to rebut.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#126

If we take the down the signs then everything will be okay. https://www.cnn.com/2026/06/13/politics/judge-ruling-nationa... > At South Carolina’s Fort Sumter National Monument, a sign that included details on the looming impacts of climate change, including information on how “rising seas could inundate most of the fort’s walls and flood the historic parade ground” was removed in its entirety.

also we can close our eyes and stop monitoring it

https://edition.cnn.com/2026/06/03/climate/ocean-monitoring-...

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#127
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> have 2 kids or fewer This is at odds with lots of other relevant topics that go beyond just "consumption". 2 or fewer is below the replacement rate of 2.1 This _has_ already happened, but there are a lot of voices voicing a lot of reasons why they believe that that might actually be not the best situation.

Below replacement would be terrifying if there were one thousand humans, it would be worrying if there were a million, and at least worthy of consideration if there were a hundred million, but there are almost ten billion simultaneous humans, we're fine.

>Below replacement would be terrifying if there were one thousand humans,

The funny part is that it should terrify you whether there are 10 humans or 10 billion. At the current rates, it's over in about 12-13 generations regardless of the number you start with. That's how it works... no matter how big the starting number, it's how many generations you have left.

Think of it this way? You know the dumb story they taught us in school, about the guy whose payment from the king for doing something clever was to have one grain of rice on the first chess square, and 2 on the second, 4 on the third, and so on... and how it bankrupted the king long before the 64th square? That's the same math with fertility rate of 1.0! (The Chinese have a fertility rate of 1.0, famously.) Each generation will be half the size of the previous. But how long before that is effectively zero? Will it be 1 million years, 250,000 years? No, about 300ish. 300 years. But long before you reach that point, your civilization has fallen apart. Those last 4 or 5 generations live life without electricity, anything but muscle power, or metallurgy.

And China's fertility rate isn't even the lowest! South Korea's rate just dropped to around 0.5! That's where each generation is one quarter the size of the previous.

The best part of all is that these rates haven't even bottomed out. We will almost certainly see rates right around 0 long before the century ends.

>but there are almost ten billion simultaneous humans, we're fine.

At least math illiteracy ought to console you guys towards the end.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#128
post #51

The sad thing about humans is that under capitalism, capital consumes public goods like nature. Then, when those public goods degrade and harm the human species, the capital class that actively consumed those public goods refuses to help restore them and instead cries that it's all a lie

It isn't simply capitalism. What system could handle this with grace? The only solution is world-wide care, which can only be achieved through civilization, education. Using an old-fashioned word: Bildung (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bildung). That could lead to the moderation required, but social-democracy is dead, and other political ideologies can't deliver. Hedonism triggered by material well-being in the last decades will kill us.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mmm, ecofascism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecofascism

Hmm nah, I'm thinking beyond that, like a full wipe and reset back to primordial ooze stage. Although that's pretty unlikely as humans will be fully wiped out as a species before conditions get to the point of triggering a full reset, and cockroaches at least are notorious for surviving the most inhospitable conditions ever. Theoretically, a device could be built that triggers it though.

He loved humanity. He just didn't care for humans.

Re: A 'cold blob' in the Atlantic could be a sign of AMOC shutdown

#130
post #37
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am interested in your implication that European farmers would have someone other than themselves to blame for this outcome. As a whole they are at least as backwards as American farmers. They are largely deniers of climate change either as a thing altogether or as something attributable to man, or are prone to believing it helps them with longer growing seasons, and their main political activity is protesting any c…

Well for one example of such case: German farmers (if there are any) could argue whether all those nuclear plants shutdowns were really for the best.

I am even more intrigued by the "no German farmers" hypothesis.
Post reply on HN