Live data from Hacker News

VLC for the new Windows 8 User Experience fundraiser

videolan.org

31–34 of 34 posts

Re: VLC for the new Windows 8 User Experience fundraiser

#31

I think it is a nice idea to finance the development via Kickstarter. I think this could become much more common for common big open source projects, i.e. some particular interesting missing feature or redesign which might need anyway some professional designer or so - financed by the community. And if I am interested in the particular feature, I am also very open to spend a bit money there. Also, by doing separate c…

Another thought, going even further: I would also very happy to work on many other open source projects if I would be paid for. Maybe there could be an open platform similar to Kickstarter but maybe the users itself could suggest features and obligatory say how much money they would spend. And developers would say on what things they would want to work on. In the end, probably the project maintainers would then decid…

Such a thing actually already exists! Take a look at BountySource: https://www.bountysource.com/

As a backer you can put cash bounties on Github issues (other trackers to come) and when a project committer accepts a pull request for that issue, the developer gets paid.

On the flip side, we're about to launch Fundraisers, which is very similar to the Kickstarter model: create a project spec and get it funded. We're building specifically for open source, rather than a generic platform.

We'd love to hear your thoughts! (#bountysource on freenode)

Re: VLC for the new Windows 8 User Experience fundraiser

#32
post #6
post #4

1) It's 2012 and we still need third party software to watch videos? I understand VLC does other stuff, but the reason most people use and install it is just to watch videos; 2) This seems like an awful lot of money, not to mention the precedent it sets, just to craft an interface for what is, ultimately, a transient 'design language'. Metro is ugly and a UX nightmare. It will be replaced with something completely ne…

With regard to point #1 I generally find VLC to be much more forgiving than the generic video players built into Windows or Mac OS X. VLC will often play damaged video files and all sorts of random, slightly corrupted files found on file sharing sites, etc. With regard to point #2 it is more than just a new interface look for VLC. It will require extensive rewriting to work within the Windows sandbox using appropriat…

The best description of VLC was that the icon is a traffic cone because it will actually play one. :)

Re: VLC for the new Windows 8 User Experience fundraiser

#33
post #18

"VLC for Windows 8 might not be applicable for the store." And that's a major problem. Without distribution on the Windows Store, this thing isn't going to see any kind of mass adoption. I'd be wary about funding until they work out whether their code and licenses pass the Store certification requirements.

Well, we hope this is enough... http://www.jbkempf.com/blog/post/2012/Windows-Store-and-the-...

Re: VLC for the new Windows 8 User Experience fundraiser

#34

If you'll remember, Rémi Denis-Courmont made such a big stink about keeping VLC out of walled gardens that Apple was forced to remove it from the App Store. So my question is: why does VLC suddenly WANT to be in a walled garden now that Windows is following suit?

because VLC is not owned by Rémi Denis-Courmont, and not everyone agrees on his move towards AppStore.
Post reply on HN