Live data from Hacker News

A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

blog.lopp.net

171–180 of 248 posts

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#171

Parents need to parent. Full stop. This means the parents of adult scammers too. Every scammer has a mother and father who are failing them. If they were doing their jobs, this wouldn't be happening.

A LOT of this is from the chinese triad in the Golden Triangle in Cambodia who use kidnapped people and abuse them

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#172
post #4

Honestly, stop the KYC regime everywhere else . We're making our law enforcement's job marginally easier, by making the criminals' job infinitely easier by creating millions of juicy PII honeypots. No, you don't need my phone #, real name, captcha.. if you think you do, realign your incentives, and rethink what else can be used for your real need instead.

Absolutely. And this is why I don't give any business my real name, phone number, or other personal information. Starbucks does not need to know my name or email to make my coffee. If a company insists on an app or some kind of registration, they lose my business, plain and simple.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#173
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The crazy thing is that a simple 9-digit number (that you must give away for many things) can ruin your life if it gets public. The US seems so backwards at times.

at times? we can't even decide if women are allowed to control their own bodies. we're now open to states stopping people with dark skin from voting, and we have giant internment camps where we keep innocent men, women, children because they have a spanish accent. vaccines are apparently not a worldwide health miracle, education is overrated, we're bringing back jobs in coal and oil, and invading/destabilizing latin…

[flagged]

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#174

Parents need to parent. Full stop. This means the parents of adult scammers too. Every scammer has a mother and father who are failing them. If they were doing their jobs, this wouldn't be happening.

They're always calling from random countries anyway. Maybe we can tell (not ask) other countries to do their job and clamp down on these scam houses.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#175

Parents need to parent. Full stop. This means the parents of adult scammers too. Every scammer has a mother and father who are failing them. If they were doing their jobs, this wouldn't be happening.

A LOT of this is from the chinese triad in the Golden Triangle in Cambodia who use kidnapped people and abuse them

[deleted]

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#176

Parents need to parent. Full stop. This means the parents of adult scammers too. Every scammer has a mother and father who are failing them. If they were doing their jobs, this wouldn't be happening.

They're always calling from random countries anyway. Maybe we can tell (not ask) other countries to do their job and clamp down on these scam houses.

Do they not have parents in random countries?

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#177

We really just need telcos to stop allowing caller id spoofing. Doesn’t even need your name, but with a real number we could actually report these scams. You can still allow people to hide it, but then by default every non-business phone should block calls with hidden numbers.

Medical offices hide their numbers for very good reasons: if you've got an abusive spouse, you often don't want the medical office in your call history. Which results in a lot of very important calls being ignored.

Unless I'm missing something, this doesn't seem hard to fix: just let users decide whether hidden numbers should be ignored or received.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#178

Phone numbers are just a liability: - It is kind of expensive, - You are forced to provide it to many official institutions, - It is the default or mandatory insecure 2FA for many institutions, - It always get leaked somewhere and is one of the most common/reliable identifier. We still have them around governments and telcos love it and old people and scammers are its last users.

The cost is a feature. Kinda also the case with IPv4 addresses.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're always calling from random countries anyway. Maybe we can tell (not ask) other countries to do their job and clamp down on these scam houses.

Do they not have parents in random countries?

Probably, maybe not. Yeah it'd be great if the entire world were prosperous and happy, until then we need a way to make spam calls harder.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#180

We really just need telcos to stop allowing caller id spoofing. Doesn’t even need your name, but with a real number we could actually report these scams. You can still allow people to hide it, but then by default every non-business phone should block calls with hidden numbers.

Medical offices hide their numbers for very good reasons: if you've got an abusive spouse, you often don't want the medical office in your call history. Which results in a lot of very important calls being ignored.

Stopping caller ID spoofing doesn't have to mean caller ID is always enabled. You should be able to make a call with NO caller id, but not a call with somebody else's caller id.
Post reply on HN