Live data from Hacker News

The Unsung Hero of the Lord of the Rings (2025)

theculturist.io

11–20 of 44 posts

Re: The Unsung Hero of the Lord of the Rings (2025)

#11
The article is the "Chad Tom Bombdadil" meme from reddit, but somehow watered down to multiple pages of text.

>Barges into the narrative.

>Sings a song about how he's older than the world.

>Puts on and takes off the Ring with no effect.

>Refuses to elaborate.

>Leaves.

Re: The Unsung Hero of the Lord of the Rings (2025)

#15
post #5

> overlooked by a huge swathe of readers I think there is no one who read LoTR and ignored Tom Bombadil. If anything, they give him too much importance.

I don't recall him having any impact on the story. The movie didn't lose anything by omitting the detour. To me it's like hedonistic gods in Buddhism--all powerful but not practically consequential to humans. I thought it was going say Samwise.

Sam is the unsung hero. Tom however did hook them up with weapons iirc.

Re: The Unsung Hero of the Lord of the Rings (2025)

#18
post #5

> overlooked by a huge swathe of readers I think there is no one who read LoTR and ignored Tom Bombadil. If anything, they give him too much importance.

I don't recall him having any impact on the story. The movie didn't lose anything by omitting the detour. To me it's like hedonistic gods in Buddhism--all powerful but not practically consequential to humans. I thought it was going say Samwise.

The barrow wights and old man willow are kind of cool.

Re: The Unsung Hero of the Lord of the Rings (2025)

#19
post #5

> overlooked by a huge swathe of readers I think there is no one who read LoTR and ignored Tom Bombadil. If anything, they give him too much importance.

I don't recall him having any impact on the story. The movie didn't lose anything by omitting the detour. To me it's like hedonistic gods in Buddhism--all powerful but not practically consequential to humans. I thought it was going say Samwise.

> I don't recall him having any impact on the story.

Well, he did rescue the hobbits from the Barrow Downs, and gave Merry Brandybuck one of the swords of Westernesse with which Merry ultimately wounded the Lord of the Nazgûl and thus permitted Eowyn to slay him in the battle of the Pelennor Fields...

Post reply on HN