Live data from Hacker News

Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

sseh.uchicago.edu

31–40 of 87 posts

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#31

I can recommend the excellent novels Concrete Island [0] and High-Rise [1] from the same author. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_Island [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Rise_(novel)

I mean that author is JG Ballard, he’s a legend with many classic works. There’s like at least two or three dozen articles, short story collections and novels of his that are worth reading. He’s one of the top dystopian fiction writers of all time.

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean it's pretty obvious from the very first paragraph, isn't it? > By good luck we have been able to make an emergency landing on this uninhabited space station. There have been no casualties. We all count ourselves fortunate to have found safe haven at a moment when the expedition was clearly set on disaster. Lots of short stories on HN have just their original title with nothing like [Novella] or whatever, seems…

Sure but isn't that the definition of clickbait?

HN is starting to grind my tits with the amount of clickbaity articles of late.

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#33
post #7

Making a modern analogy, reading this feels kinda similar to reading about the Backrooms, but with a bigger, existential dread. Amazing.

I was also thinking of this story around the Backrooms lore (since you can find references that it is infinite or planet-sized repeating). Of course I couldn't remember enough to have it pop up on Google or ChatGPT. Grateful that someone posted it.

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#34

Annoying nitpick: > Our solar system and its planets, the millions of other solar systems that constitute our galaxy, and the island universes themselves all lie within the boundaries of the station. The station is coeval with the cosmos [...] > Estimated diameter: 15,000 light years. Uhmm.. Yes I know, the entire construction is not striving for realism and neither should be taken literally.

If you like nitpicking, Poe's short story *The unparalleled Adventure of One Hans Pfall" [1] should keep you busy a couple of days ;-) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unparalleled_Adventure_of_...

But here it's not about a generic lack of realism (there's plenty of details you could point to, but it would be of course silly) but simply the internal contradiction in what the main character says: claims that the station is "as big as the cosmos" and two lines later provides an estimate for its diameter that is grossly inconsistent with that same assessment. Unless they live in a universe that is only 15k years old, which is also possible (but clearly not serving a purpose in the story).

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#35
post #12

I feel this should have a note that it's fictional in the title. I clicked this expecting to read about some kind of space race development with China or Russia.

I mean it's pretty obvious from the very first paragraph, isn't it? > By good luck we have been able to make an emergency landing on this uninhabited space station. There have been no casualties. We all count ourselves fortunate to have found safe haven at a moment when the expedition was clearly set on disaster. Lots of short stories on HN have just their original title with nothing like [Novella] or whatever, seems…

I expected it to be fiction from the title, and knew it was from the structure, before even reading any text.

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#36
just read it and not entirely sure what the allegory was, if any.

some ideas off the top of my head:

- "humans invent meaning after losing orientation": instead of simply accepting reality (we cant comprhened, our instruments cant measure this, we are lost etc) they turn helplessness into theology

- "science-becomes-religion": hypotheses, measurements revise previous findings into increasing absurdity which eventually becomes religion.

-" life as a waiting room": the station is an allegory for life or conciousness. we're all solitary voyagers on our infinite journey thru the "waiting rooms" of our existence. the journey is the destination etc

curious to hear other riffs/takes on this

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#37
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pretty sure this is a Tardis bigger-on-the-inside situation

Then where is the 15k lightyears figure supposed to come from?

I took those distance estimates to mean "as measured by the instruments".

The longer they're in it, the larger the estimate, and they've hypothesized that it will approach the size of the universe itself.

Re: Report on an Unidentified Space Station – J.G. Ballard (1982)

#38
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then where is the 15k lightyears figure supposed to come from?

I took those distance estimates to mean "as measured by the instruments". The longer they're in it, the larger the estimate, and they've hypothesized that it will approach the size of the universe itself.

Also worth noting that they’ve already crossed their own tracks at least once - thus their estimate is probably extremely suspect
Post reply on HN