Live data from Hacker News

US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

bbc.com

21–30 of 160 posts

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#22
post #6

This idea is adorable, but ultimately untenable if either country drifts in its views on how its citizens should behave. I suspect that Canada isn't fond of how Americans view guns, and I suspect that the US is not quite on board with blasphemy/hurty-words laws. I suspect the divergence will grow.

Yeah, could be that, could be the open threat of invasion, I dunno.

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#23
post #6

This idea is adorable, but ultimately untenable if either country drifts in its views on how its citizens should behave. I suspect that Canada isn't fond of how Americans view guns, and I suspect that the US is not quite on board with blasphemy/hurty-words laws. I suspect the divergence will grow.

Canada technically had a blasphemy law on the books until 2018, but it was basically gathering dust, the last conviction was in 1927.

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#25
post #6

This idea is adorable, but ultimately untenable if either country drifts in its views on how its citizens should behave. I suspect that Canada isn't fond of how Americans view guns, and I suspect that the US is not quite on board with blasphemy/hurty-words laws. I suspect the divergence will grow.

I don't agree with most of what Germany does and I am sure they are not very fond of our (Switzerland) "liberal" gun laws, yet I can just walk/drive or take a train across the border and no one gives 2 cents.

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#26
post #6

This idea is adorable, but ultimately untenable if either country drifts in its views on how its citizens should behave. I suspect that Canada isn't fond of how Americans view guns, and I suspect that the US is not quite on board with blasphemy/hurty-words laws. I suspect the divergence will grow.

Ultimately its one country unilaterally acted the fool and is reaping the rewards of that idiocy. Any other explanation of what's going on is either willfully blind or so uninformed that they should not share their ideas with others.

My god, they want it so desperately to be something else they're willing to resort to complete misinformation.

There's some bizarre pseudo-libertarian contingent out there that seems to genuinely believing that Canada is some place where we arrest people with Jordan Peterson books off the street and that the Ottawa "trucker" convoy was some sort of colour revolution brutally stamped out by a Communist Regime(tm).

(When actually if said "truckers" had tried what they did on the US side of the border, DHS would have just shot them, and the vaccination law that they were supposedly protesting was a law demanded by the US and the Trudeau gov't tried multiple times to have it delayed/deferred)

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#27
post #5

It's not an unfair reaction to the main entrance being closed, but it is a little sad. The northern border used to be so much more flexible and I don't see any real benefits from doing all this.

I really hope we get back to times where we were really best friends. It was good for both countries and was a model for international relationships/partnerships.

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#29
post #5

It's not an unfair reaction to the main entrance being closed, but it is a little sad. The northern border used to be so much more flexible and I don't see any real benefits from doing all this.

I really hope we get back to times where we were really best friends. It was good for both countries and was a model for international relationships/partnerships.

Write your congressman. If congress decides the people care things will change, but when they hear nothing they don't care.

Re: US-Canada border library gets new Quebec-only entrance

#30
Related: episode 653 of 99% Invisible mentions Peace Arch Park, which is along the US-Canada border in Blaine, Washington, and Surrey, British Columbia. Anyone from either country can enter the park and mingle with people from the other country. There's supposedly strong incentive, because of a treaty from the War of 1812, for both countries to keep their side of the park open:

If Canada broke the treaty, in theory, the U.S. could lay claim to parts of Ontario and Quebec. And if America broke it, Canada could get parts of Maine, Michigan, and Wisconsin. So, basically, North American geography as we know it is contingent on this early 1800s treaty remaining in effect.

The podcast was from December -- an eternity ago in these interesting times -- and I don't know whether anything has changed since then.

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/653-beyond-the-99-inv...

Post reply on HN