Live data from Hacker News

World Capitals Voronoi

jasondavies.com

51–60 of 73 posts

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#51
Very nice.

I guess most dutchies would disagree with the decision to pick De Hague as the Main Capital, though :-)

While all power is in De Hague , Amsterdam definitely is the Capital. De Hague is for complaining about, Amsterdam is for celebrating.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#52

Very nice. I guess most dutchies would disagree with the decision to pick De Hague as the Main Capital, though :-) While all power is in De Hague , Amsterdam definitely is the Capital. De Hague is for complaining about, Amsterdam is for celebrating.

Fixed. It was originally Amsterdam, but I was experimenting with resolving ambiguous capitals by using the de facto seat of government, based on other feedback here (e.g. South Africa originally had multiple capitals). I've switched back to the more familiar atlas capital in ambiguous cases.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#54
Perhaps you should limit it to capital cities or states with a certain population size. Including all the European microstates does not seem appropriate to me; Andorra, Monaco, San Marino and the Vatican have very varying degrees of independence and geopolitical significance.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#56
It took me this map to realize the capital of Sri Lanka is Sri Jayawardenepura Kotte, and not Colombo as I thought for over 30 years.

Always interesting to find capital cities which are in fact not the most famous cities from that country. Makes for great trivia questions.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#57

Taipei claiming a big chunk of the PRC. Probably go down as well as Ottawa and Mexico City claiming big chunks of the USA

The bad news is that we lose Windsor in this trade. The good news is that we pick up Seattle and Minneapolis.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#58

It took me this map to realize the capital of Sri Lanka is Sri Jayawardenepura Kotte, and not Colombo as I thought for over 30 years. Always interesting to find capital cities which are in fact not the most famous cities from that country. Makes for great trivia questions.

Not quite - it's somewhat like South Africa in that certain institutions are in Colombo and others in Kotte (specifically the legislature is in Kotte). In addition, Kotte and Colombo are nearly adjacent.

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#59

It would be interesting to see a map which was not minimizing [distance to capital] but instead minimized [distance to capital]/sqrt([national population]). The latter would be more robust against Sybil attacks.

I was wondering what kind of metric could be used to visualize a nation’s ability to project power. Maybe some ratio involving the furthest distance from the capital city to the nation’s border? I’m curious why the sqrt of the population in the denominator?

I think that's supposed to be read as "or"? (I momentarily had the same confusion myself.)

Re: World Capitals Voronoi

#60

Perhaps you should limit it to capital cities or states with a certain population size. Including all the European microstates does not seem appropriate to me; Andorra, Monaco, San Marino and the Vatican have very varying degrees of independence and geopolitical significance.

Regardless of how one selects states there will always be comments saying it was done wrong. Don't fall into this trap, just stick with one of the UN lists as has already been done here (looks like members+recognized observer states) and accept not everyone can be perfectly pleased with what is considered a state or not.

Interactive data filters would definitely be fun on its own account though. E.g. the population slider or by having a button making it the largest cities above x population instead of countries/capitals or so on with centers of states. It looks like there are several different maps on this site, such things may make it more a single experience with more overall value than the separated parts. Still cool as it is though :) just one possibility to go further with it.

Post reply on HN