Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

vorpus.github.io

71–80 of 227 posts

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#71
post #51

Adding github link for those who want to use it (I do): https://github.com/vorpus/performativeUI

wait my readme isnt performative enough yet, let me add a chart showing the star history

lol. Genuinely curious, what is your reaction to so much "actually, this is great and useful" feedback?

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#72
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think the commentary being made here is that startup websites should not be flashy. Just that, maybe they don't all need to look exactly the same as each other.

I think homogeneity is an unavoidable end game for the internet (unfortunately). At work we’ve been discussing whether to migrate off our home grown component library to Material UI. I shudder at the thought, personally. However, a compelling reason to use a ubiquitous framework is that the ubiquity means folks intuitively know how to interact with your product. Like many of us I was born into a deeply customizable I…

We're migrating our Material UI components to homemade components, since MUI doesn't cater to our needs anymore.

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#73

The most extreme virtue-signal is to go completely browser-default and have no styling whatsoever. Like lowercasing because your pinky can't be arsed to reach for the shift-key even though you've a billion dollars in series A.

I've mostly stopped caring about using using proper capitalization, commas, grammar and spelling in my writing of comments, primarily as a signal that i'm not an llm.

The problem is that omitting capitalization, commas, and so on signals, in addition to "not AI in default settings", but also "I'm part of the San Francisco AI in-crowd and Altman is my spirit animal".

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the marketing world this is called revealed preference. This stuff is A/B tested to death. Anyone trying to sell something is best served by watching people's behavior instead of listening to what they say, as the two are often different if not polar opposites.

The perspective marketing world seems toxic. From the perspective of the "consumer", it sure does feel like we are being "ignored", "tricked", or "bamboozled" when our stated preferences are ignored in favor of "revealed preference". It isn't that we have a "preference" for these things, it is far more likely that a user just doesn't have their guard up 100% of the time, and these psychological manipulations are desi…

Yeah, it is highly toxic. I'd assume that in most cases those "revealed preferences" are specifically engineered, not organic. It's taking advantage of biological reflexes and calling it a true preference.

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#75
post #28
post #3

These all look very professional for (basically) a parody library

What are the odds some companies end up using it for a real product?

Honestly I can just swap these bad boys in and ship in less than a couple hours if it'd be funny enough. I don't think they're bad designs at all, and I don't think every aspect of my business needs to be unique and obsessed over.

IMO this is like judging landscaping companies for all using similar looking shovels.

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've mostly stopped caring about using using proper capitalization, commas, grammar and spelling in my writing of comments, primarily as a signal that i'm not an llm.

If you turn on HN's "Show Dead" setting, there are tons of LLM-generated comments on stories related to AI. You can see the human(s) behind the LLM trying to fiddle with the style of comment by making them skip proper grammar, capitalization, use or avoid certain phrases, and so on. The biggest tell for LLM content, though, is just the content as a whole: it sounds fake and ungenuine, like it passed through a committ…

The uncanny valley of text. It looks and sounds like a human, but lacks the "soul" / humanity that our intuition somehow perceives.

It's really strange... I see some text with obvious tropes and sometimes I read something and there's no obvious AI trope... but it's just not human?

Re: Show HN: Performative-UI – A react component library of design tropes

#77

The most extreme virtue-signal is to go completely browser-default and have no styling whatsoever. Like lowercasing because your pinky can't be arsed to reach for the shift-key even though you've a billion dollars in series A.

https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/

My god, it's perfect.
Post reply on HN