Live data from Hacker News

Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

cnbc.com

261–270 of 1001 posts

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#261

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Orbital datacenters sound like a dangerous bet. I couldn't think of a worse place for a lot of delecate electronics.

Boomers and luddites won't let them be built on earth so no other option really

It's more unpopular than that. Not surprising since they're competing underhandedly for electricity generation with everyone else.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#263

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Water in orbit: famously cheap.

Ah yes: computation. Famous for annihilating water. Every bit you flip consumes an H2O molecule.

My job is mostly worrying about cooling paths, maintenance, power, heat transfer, lifetime of GPUs, and high performance networks. NVIDIA partner. I can drive to the datacenter. This stuff BARELY works here on Earth. Especially thermal issues.

Looking forward to watching spacex defeat physics.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#264

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would it ever be more economical to put datacenters in orbit, rather than on some dirt cheap land?

There are no NIMBYs in space. No government permitting on land use. And solar power is plentiful. It's like having a dollar store Dyson sphere. Making use of that is predicated entirely on being able to put a lot of hardware into space cheaply. SpaceX is the undisputed best at that, no one comes close. The question is whether their "best" is good enough to make space datacenters economical.

There are many Not In My Orbit people on this very page. Many current national politicians would be happy to vote AI out of orbit today. Space is not an escape from earthly politics.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#265
So Google AI will now be running partly on xAI data centers which run primarily on natural gas burned on site next to poor neighborhoods in Tennessee and Mississippi causing massive air pollution to these families and children. Is anyone else disgusted by this? I’m imagining all the people there developing lung and other issues because of this. Greed and power on full display over doing the right thing.

I’ll be switching off the Gemini model at work (Composer’s been off since their xAI deal). This is the final straw for me to move completely off Google services.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#266
post #199
post #162

Google renting infra from xAI, I did not see that coming. My understanding of what computers are doing, what companies are doing and what governments are doing seems to be getting worse day by day.

> Google renting infra from xAI, I did not see that coming. Actually that seems to be fairly logical? Hardware is what xAI has , and it's in great demand. So sell what makes you money. The real story here is that that xAI hardware is going to be running Gemini and not Grok. Which is to say: Grok basically failed as a frontier AI and they need to pivot to a business model which makes money. Obviously not everything Mu…

Strongly agree with all of this, except that charging rent for the use of an asset you own is not what economic "rent-seeking" means. I blame the dumbass economists who named it this, forever polluting the discussion to be had about regulatory capture and legalized political bribery.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#267

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Grok has plenty of "non-woke AI" cred which will make it a preferred choice for lots of government-side and politically sensitive workloads.

What do you think the term woke actually means?

I think their point is less that it really means something and more that enough customers think it means something to provide economic opportunity

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#268
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are paying for the existing earth-bound data centers SpaceXai owns.

Oh wow did not realize xai has data centers. So are they completely abandoning xai or do they just have that much capacity left over?

They have unused capacity in their Tennessee datacenter. We don't know everything but the backend of Grok probably runs in the TN datacenter. Grok is not as popular as hoped, so the TN datacenter has unused capacity.

There are other companies besides Google and Anthropic that are considering renting capacity in xaispacex's datacenters.

Global capacity for GPU hosting is tight at the moment. That TN DC is the only one not totally 110 percent already allocated for five years in the world .

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The earthbound equivalent would be strapping each chassis to the back of a dedicated solar panel and having the panel double as a giant heat sink. The problem is that doesn't work on the surface due to (at least) rain, the day/night cycle, and the cost of real estate.

Isn't a solar panel going to be a poor heatsink, though? It's flat, and thus has relatively small surface area compared to its size.

In atmosphere, yeah, relatively speaking.

But it doesn't matter since in this scenario each chassis is powered exclusively by the respective panel. How hot does a black panel sitting in the midday sun get? That's your equilibrium temperature. As long as it's within the operational limit of the device there's no problem.

The reason earthbound DCs are difficult to cool is because of density. When you match up panels to devices and shelter in their shadow you no longer have anywhere near the same power density.

Re: Google to pay SpaceX $920M a month for compute capacity at xAI data centers

#270

Wait, are these the same GPUs that were diverted from Tesla into xAI a couple of years ago?

There may be a few here, but xaispacex has bought a very large amount of nvidia GPU since then for their TN datacenter .
Post reply on HN