Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

news.ycombinator.com

311–320 of 1001 posts

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#311
post #172

I was working on a project for 2 years with about 5 engineers. It was many years before AI. It was new subject for our team, and we were pretty sure it was possible. Turned out it was not. Much later I asked AI if that kind of project is possible, and it immediately explained why it is not. Would have saved 2 years of our time...

Curious, what was the project?

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#312
post #246

I was working on a science experiment (electromagnetics) with my 10-year-old kid that was going to be demonstrated at a science fair in his school. We ran into a hiccup with the experiment that we couldn't debug ourselves. I turned on Gemini live video call to help us root cause the problem. It was able to clearly articulate all the possible issues and eventually was successful in making our apparatus work as expecte…

Neat, but I'd bet it was "guessing" that rather than actually seeing it.

If it’s “guessing” correctly 95% of the time, is that meaningfully different from “seeing” it for most practical purposes?

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#313
When the very first ChatGPT transformed a simple C "hello world" into Python. I knew it's special. I'm a very big supporter ever since, including some worried moments of pondering about what our future would look like and what's the meaning of a having a profession - especially software which defined my life from childhood - for my kids.

I'm now very good with LLMs as a user and at the system/product level but I understand it's not a simple story of replacing people. They're exponentially better than us at some things, and allow me to create things professionally which I couldn't do with an entire team of experts, but the bullshit compounds fast.

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#314

I won’t deny they are useful tools, but the hyperbole from the tech CEOs about them replacing all white collar workers in 12-18 months set the expectation so high that I’m still in the “fancy auto-complete” camp. It still feels nowhere close to replacing anyone, at least where I work. While useful, they haven’t been anywhere close to as useful as promised. Hallucinations and poor guidance are still a regular day-to-d…

I think if they were more honest it would have been a nonstarter.

The amount of money these companies need seems to be all of nothing, they’re raising like it’s life or death and if you read their books or tweets they’re not shy about it

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#316
I wasn't impressed by the LLMs up until January or so when Claude Code swooped in. Until then, I felt like the LLMs were slowing me down. I have been using them for a couple of years now for coding at work, but I never really thought they brought in real value. Then in February I worked on a 1-month-ish project timeline and shrunk it to 3 days and that was it. I didn't write a single line of code in that project and I went all in with Claude Code. That was it, _the moment_ of realization. I was thoroughly impressed. I went from nothing to a tool that served several teams. Now I'm starting to see the cracks in LLMs and I'm slowly getting back to picking which task to offload to AI and which ones to do by myself.

Claude is great at coding. That's it. Outside of it, it's just god awful at pretty much everything else. ChatGPT OTOH, is good at coding, but at everything else, I find it brilliant. Gemini never made me want to stick with it. It's good, but never great for my use cases.

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#317

I bought an Alesis QS8.1 super cheap in perfect condition (was a top grade digital piano/synth in the 90s). and then i realized that ALL of the software (which i collected from defunct websites and archived on github) related to it was ancient and after a while of getting tired of using WINE every single time i decided i wanted a cross platform modern equivalent that did everything that several of these different pro…

I had that keyboard! I actually really like the piano-ish touch. I remember being sad though, when I realized they’d crammed all the sounds into I think 16MB (or was it 8?) and realizing how bad that was even by the late 90s! I think I still have mine in the garage somewhere… good times!

Re: Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

#318
There wasn't a specific moment, but I started trying to debug code and deal with general tech error messages. Suddenly something that could take hours turned into a fairly quick back and forth, fairly reliably. Not all the time, but often enough to be a straightforward timesaver.

There was a more specific moment yesterday where I found an AI pastiche of Pink Floyd in a random post on FB, and it pretty much nailed the vibe of a Gilmour solo.

All of the "This has no soul" criticism was clearly ridiculous.

I'm still not sure how I feel about this.

Post reply on HN