Live data from Hacker News

Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

quantamagazine.org

81–90 of 191 posts

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#81
post #67

"Einstein cast gravity not as a force but as the geometric bending of space and time. In a popular analogy, the fabric of space-time is like the flat expanse of a mattress, and a massive object like a star is like a bowling ball sitting on top. The weight of the bowling ball compresses the mattress, forming a dimple — matter tells space-time how to curve. In this analogy, a planet is like a smaller ball. If it rolls…

Could you be more specific? How does bending time cause the Earth to orbit the Sun?

This was a helpful visualization: https://youtu.be/U_sI9agWmEw?si=MItDfnTx1-oT_qX_

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#82
post #67

"Einstein cast gravity not as a force but as the geometric bending of space and time. In a popular analogy, the fabric of space-time is like the flat expanse of a mattress, and a massive object like a star is like a bowling ball sitting on top. The weight of the bowling ball compresses the mattress, forming a dimple — matter tells space-time how to curve. In this analogy, a planet is like a smaller ball. If it rolls…

i agree with you but i'd go even further

time and gravity are the same thing, the history of understanding physics is basically of the same nature, understanding that two things are actually one thing, which is more like philosophy but with physical confirmation

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#84
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And also, how does one bend time ?

It means clocks tick at different rates depending on where they are. Imagine spacetime as a field of local clocks. Far from the Sun, clocks tick faster. Near the Sun, clocks tick slower. A freely moving object tries to follow the straightest possible path through spacetime. But because the “time axis” changes from place to place, what counts as “straight ahead into the future” tilts slightly inward near the Sun. So t…

Does the atmosphere stay attached to the earth due to the bending of time?

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you be more specific? How does bending time cause the Earth to orbit the Sun?

And also, how does one bend time ?

It's much simpler than anyone thought:

https://youtu.be/A-2XQQDD6QQ

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you be more specific? How does bending time cause the Earth to orbit the Sun?

And also, how does one bend time ?

Same way you bend space. In GR, time is just another dimension of a slightly different flavor.

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#87
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you be more specific? How does bending time cause the Earth to orbit the Sun?

This was a helpful visualization: https://youtu.be/U_sI9agWmEw?si=MItDfnTx1-oT_qX_

I skimmed the video, but it's definitely the same example that finally made this make sense to me.

I always hated the ball and sheet example simply because it was describing gravity with gravity. It felt fundamentally wrong.

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#88
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It means clocks tick at different rates depending on where they are. Imagine spacetime as a field of local clocks. Far from the Sun, clocks tick faster. Near the Sun, clocks tick slower. A freely moving object tries to follow the straightest possible path through spacetime. But because the “time axis” changes from place to place, what counts as “straight ahead into the future” tilts slightly inward near the Sun. So t…

Does the atmosphere stay attached to the earth due to the bending of time?

That's right -- the atmosphere stays attached to the Earth mostly thanks to gravity, and the Earth's gravity in GR is almost entirely the gradient in clock rate near the Earth.

Near Earth’s surface, clocks lower down tick very slightly slower than clocks higher up. The change in tick rate is on the order of 10^(-16) per meter. While extremely small, that's enough to generate the familiar 9.8 m/s^2 spatial acceleration we experience. Such a small gradient in clock rates generates macrosopically noticeable spatial accelerations because the "translation" factor is c^2, a tremendously large number.

Now, if I wanted to cover all my bases here, I'd need to point out that gravity does also bend space -- that is just not a relevant factor for "ordinary" gravity acting on relatively slow moving matter (like the Earth itself, or the Earth's atmosphere). For instance, for light itself, spatial bending is just as important (in fact, the gravitational deflection of light by a weak static gravitational field is controlled by a near 50/50 split between spatial and temporal effects). Near a massive black hole, it's not that simple and can't meaningfully be understood in terms of "time" and "space" effects being independently separated.

Re: Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

See the end of the article, after further research quantum gravity could be simulated on a quantum computer. The links between research on quantum computing and quantum gravity are fascinating anyway!

Simulating it on a computer, even a "quantum computer", is not the same as testing it against actual reality.

Ah. You're assuming we're not living in a simulation?
Post reply on HN