Live data from Hacker News

Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

newscientist.com

1–10 of 28 posts

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#3
post #2

I has tennis elbow a while ago. Was going to see the doctor but there was a wait. Looked up natural antiinflamatories. Turmeric came up. Did turmeric and black pepper milkshakes for a week and it fixed it.

Or the turmeric did nothing and it fixed itself the way the vast majority of injuries heal.

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#4
post #2

I has tennis elbow a while ago. Was going to see the doctor but there was a wait. Looked up natural antiinflamatories. Turmeric came up. Did turmeric and black pepper milkshakes for a week and it fixed it.

I hear you. The problem is... It might have just gotten better by itself. Hard to know.

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#5
post #2

I has tennis elbow a while ago. Was going to see the doctor but there was a wait. Looked up natural antiinflamatories. Turmeric came up. Did turmeric and black pepper milkshakes for a week and it fixed it.

How long had the problem persisted before you considered going to the doctor?

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#7
If turmeric had health benefits, we would expect India to be the world leader in that particular benefit. There are so few areas in which India is a leader that the answer is obviously no.

Like I get that turmeric is exotic and that a lot of non-Indians take turmeric pills and supplements, but Indian food has tons of turmeric as a normal ingredient. We would go through bottles and bags of the stuff like nothing. I don't understand these supplements and the treatment of turmeric as a medicine. Some supplements even tell you to talk to your doctor before eating turmeric! That's crazy. What next, talk to your therapist before taking garlic?

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#8
post #7

If turmeric had health benefits, we would expect India to be the world leader in that particular benefit. There are so few areas in which India is a leader that the answer is obviously no. Like I get that turmeric is exotic and that a lot of non-Indians take turmeric pills and supplements, but Indian food has tons of turmeric as a normal ingredient. We would go through bottles and bags of the stuff like nothing. I do…

Like so many things, it may even be backwards: https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/your-herb...

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#9
Somewhat useless article. To summarize, we have anecdotes suggesting they may work but no one has figured out how to prove or disprove it in a study, and the author has some doubts. Meanwhile supplements can be dangerous if you take too much or have a liver condition, or if you buy them from an unreputable source, as with every other substance on earth. Author confirms it tastes good in milk.

Re: Do turmeric and curcumin have any actual health benefits?

#10
post #2

I has tennis elbow a while ago. Was going to see the doctor but there was a wait. Looked up natural antiinflamatories. Turmeric came up. Did turmeric and black pepper milkshakes for a week and it fixed it.

Or the turmeric did nothing and it fixed itself the way the vast majority of injuries heal.

Turmeric always does something.

Whether it’s enough to make a difference in your case depends.

Post reply on HN