Live data from Hacker News

Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

nytimes.com

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#11

Scorcese understands that Hollywood's ultimate limiting factor is the number of available actors. A finite pool of actors means a finite pool of movies. Removing this limitation means that, just like an AI image generator can generate any image imaginable, a future movie generator will be able to generate every movie imaginable, at the click of a button.

There is not a shortage of actors.

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#12

Scorcese understands that Hollywood's ultimate limiting factor is the number of available actors. A finite pool of actors means a finite pool of movies. Removing this limitation means that, just like an AI image generator can generate any image imaginable, a future movie generator will be able to generate every movie imaginable, at the click of a button.

Instead of using AI actors, couldn't we address Hollywood's actor shortage some other way?

For example, we could tap the federal Strategic Actor Reserve, or import actors from actor-rich countries such as France and Belgium.

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#13

Scorcese understands that Hollywood's ultimate limiting factor is the number of available actors. A finite pool of actors means a finite pool of movies. Removing this limitation means that, just like an AI image generator can generate any image imaginable, a future movie generator will be able to generate every movie imaginable, at the click of a button.

There is not a shortage of actors.

So much so people do anything to try to become an actor, the ones that make i are an incredibly small fraction of the actual pool. Worse, most of those you see on the screen are also not rich or making bank, sometimes they're just paying the bills.

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#15

Scorcese understands that Hollywood's ultimate limiting factor is the number of available actors. A finite pool of actors means a finite pool of movies. Removing this limitation means that, just like an AI image generator can generate any image imaginable, a future movie generator will be able to generate every movie imaginable, at the click of a button.

I don't think anyone living in LA would claim there's a shortage of actors.

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#18

Scorcese understands that Hollywood's ultimate limiting factor is the number of available actors. A finite pool of actors means a finite pool of movies. Removing this limitation means that, just like an AI image generator can generate any image imaginable, a future movie generator will be able to generate every movie imaginable, at the click of a button.

Instead of using AI actors, couldn't we address Hollywood's actor shortage some other way? For example, we could tap the federal Strategic Actor Reserve, or import actors from actor-rich countries such as France and Belgium.

We could invade other countries and take their actors. We could reinstate the actor's draft or do mandatory 1-2 years actor's service like some other countries do

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#19

I've noticed a tendency among people who have built careers known for visionary, forward-thinking work that they hesitate to make the natural move into more "conservative" positions/approaches as they age. This leads to missteps, because as one ages, one inevitably becomes further removed from the zeitgeist. On paper, embracing AI might seem like a great idea if you don't want to become an old fogey, but not all chan…

Given that, according to the article, he's just using it for storyboarding, in attempt to better communicate a vision to a range of human contributors, it's really unclear how this decision will "age badly." either this is a stronger way to create storyboards or it isn't.

Presumably he has the experience to evaluate if this is likely to actually help or not. Or at least if it is worth exploring.

It is rather unclear why you believe he is likely wrong, aside from conjuring up rather ageist speculations about his motives.

Re: Martin Scorsese Is Embracing A.I.

#20
post #14

A.I. like in generating crowds, simulating physics, improving effects... or Large Language Models and Image Generation? AI means a lot of different things, I wish I could read the article.

generative ai for story-boarding.

(i typically find nytimes works if you disable scripts)

Post reply on HN