Live data from Hacker News

Macbook air Or Macbook pro

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 26 posts

Re: Macbook air Or Macbook pro

#3
Depends on how much you want to spend. The Macbook Pro models generally have faster CPUs so you'll see a benefit there in terms of compilation time and general snappiness.

The MBP gives you the option of the Retina display though. My personal opinion is that that in and of itself is worth the extra cost :P. If you're going for the 13", be aware of the fact that it can be a little bit laggy when you're trying to something graphically intensive. Depending on your use case, you might be better off getting the standard MBP if that bothers you.

Re: Macbook air Or Macbook pro

#4
Coming from a person who has owned both. I can say for sure that it just doesn't matter. Some will say that the pro has more ports and is more of a power beast, but given all that let me ask you the following. 1. You are starting to program, consider yourself at least a few months out till you get into a world where you will start programming device drivers. 2. When was the last time you actually used a dvd drive? Everything is on the internet or wirelessly available.

Most of the work that I have done, ranging from device drivers to now, distributed systems, my macbook air sufficed. Programming has never 'required' me to have a retina display. If you asked the question with the context of media or photo editing, my answer would be different.

My setup is as follows: 1. Macbook air 11" (portability is the key) 2. Apple wireless keyboard and mouse 3. Apple 27" display connected via thunderbolt. (wired network). You may substitute with any other good monitor.

The desktop setup is just a plain must. Anyone who says 11" or 13" or even 15" is enough for working, has just never worked on a big screen long enough. It just increases your productivity by an order of magnitude. Imagine the time saved by having multiple windows/terminals and documentation right in front of you and not having to switch between the two.

So, to end it all. Get a decent compact machine that you can take with you, and use on the go. And get yourself a good desktop setup when you want to get serious stuff done. Also, the desktop setup (personally) focuses you into a simple and distraction free zone, allowing you to be more productive.

Re: Macbook air Or Macbook pro

#6
You need to give us more to go on. You can program C/C++ on a Raspberry Pi without issue.

So clearly you aren't buying either machine to learn to program C/C++ on. Any PC or computer made in the last thirty years would be equally good for that.

So tell us your real requirements (e.g. gaming, DVDs, digital video, etc) and what you really do day to day (e.g. mobile users, "workstation replacement," etc)?

Re: Macbook air Or Macbook pro

#7
probably doesn't matter too much. I like a pro because you can upgrade the HDD and ram on your own and avoid apple's insane upgrade prices

edit: the standard MBP, I've heard terrible things about the retina pros being generally laggy

Re: Macbook air Or Macbook pro

#10

If you don't need to use any Mac OS specific software then you could get a Windows laptop, the hardware is generally cheaper. If it must be an Apple then the Air is more than suitable for a bit of coding.

Such a '90s cliché. Cheaper does not always mean better value, and it is often at the expense of build/longevity.

Apple does overcharge on memory/disk upgrades (as does MS, just look at the ahem 32gb Surface with 16gb of free space).

But generally I find Apple a solid buy.

Post reply on HN