The newest Instagram “exploit” is the goofiest I've seen

Nothing says you are an advanced stupid company than using AI to implement the stupid. This is security I doubt even a college student would implement. Does Meta have a CSO? The correct answer is they don't, even though some body might occupy the title.

Of course it's always possible that they simply don't care who has your account, as long as they get money.

I had to go through the account recovery on my Facebook account once and the proof they demanded was that I match a bunch of pictures of friends to their names. I think it took 3 tries over multiple days to actually get it unlocked because it turns out I such really remember a lot of the people I met 20 years ago and friended on Facebook.

I don’t recall why I had to go through this song and dance. Very plausibly the account was still associated with an old school address that I could no longer access. So yeah, account recovery is hard. How do you prove someone owns an account when they’ve lost the things they are supposed to use to prove ownership?

I'm horrified with how poor Meta's use of AI is recently. Here's a list of the issues both me and my wife have been plagued with over the past few weeks. It's really quite an achievement to be this terrible. 1. My personal Facebook received 3 violations restricting my ability to manage ANY Page until April 2027 (lol). The trigger... I deleted 3 unused Pages. These Pages I had created years ago in preparation for projects that never came to fruition, and had never posted any content. THe pages were 'scheduled for deletion', and when that day came (around a month later?), boom, I'm hit with a 1 month restriction which later converted itself into a 1 year restriction after I waited out the month. No Appeal button. I'm expected to wait for a year to manage my new page? All over something that is NOT a violation, just for deleting old pages. Get out of here. Smart system.

2. I pay for Meta Verified on Instagram and for the past 2 weeks "Enhanced support" leads me to a broken interface. "Page isn't available right now". So, what am I paying for exactly?

3. It seems you can use Meta's AI Assistant to sometimes get through to a human. I've done this twice now, and both times my case has been escalated to a different team (apparently) yet I never get an email, I never get an update in the chat (the chat ENDS immediately after the phone call with support), and the issue is never resolved. It's been 2 weeks. The case says "Completed", with no response. Worthless as always.

4. My wife creates content on Instagram and has had her account suspended multiple times now for "Account Integrity". I assume the system thinks she's not the person in the content, despite providing her valid email, phone number, video selfie, and 2 types of ID (passport & driver's license) multiple times. What's hilarious is the passport was accepted on of her accounts (they wiped out everything on her Account Center), but another account was rejected. Great AI, same passport, exact same lighting... different outcome.

So as it stands, we're both fucked on both facebook and instagram thanks to awful AI moderation, and fucked further thanks to awful AI support. No resolution in sight. The incompetence is next level. I really don't see this getting resolved. This already happened to my wife earlier in February, she managed to get one account back, and a month later she's hit with the same identity issues.

Using AI for both the moderation and the support makes me sick. The same poor AI that incorrectly flagged me and my wife's accounts for a load of incorrect bullshit is the same system that's meant to help resolve it? Of course it's going to side with its own poor decision. YouTube seems to do the same thing and auto-reject appeals in seconds. Really smart /s

I believe we need enforcement that social platforms should NOT be using AI to perform destructive actions without human intervention. Noone should ever lose their accounts because of AI mistakes. AI should be used to surface potential issues which get passed to a HUMAN to double check before applying the action. AI simply isn't good enough to have full control.

Fucking pissed off and even angier now I've had to write all this up and remind myself just how ridiculous the situation is. Sorry for the rant, but losing your accounts you put work into is very crushing and demotivating. Being accused of these violations fills us both with so much resent for the companies running this shit.

Sam Cofounder Postmates

On the off-chance there's anyone at Meta seeing this (@Wirah on twitter)

Had to make this new username as my original (samstr) comment doesn't show up. No idea why. Probably shit AI

> your bank could shut phishers down cold by requiring wire transfers to be authorized in person but they don’t want to pay staff or risk you being upset by a transaction taking an extra hour so they don’t.

Isn't this essentially what just recently happened to the Pope? Then there were people here doing the rest of your comment for him saying how egregious it was for them to ask for an in person authorization. It sounded like all he was trying to do was update his address, but changing your address from one in Chicago to one in a European country absolutely sounds like something a phisher would be trying to do.

> People were sold on the Internet with "you can do things online conveniently" and reintroducing the need to physically go somewhere negates that angle entirely

But how often does one need to do recovery procedures like this?

How much less convenient is it for everyone else to be at risk of their account being taken over?