Live data from Hacker News

Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

techcrunch.com

41–50 of 533 posts

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#41

It's a real shame private messaging has ended up being almost exclusively closed-source without any kind of open API.

In the EU at least WhatsApp is being forced to interop with other messaging apps. I believe it's being rolled out at the moment.

Yeah, there are precisely two apps that can exchange with Whatsapp: one is still in beta, the other is by invite only, and for "professional networking" or something like that. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46746476

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#43

Who is this for? Is it just a way to monetize dying platforms before they inevitably become worthless?

The last stage of Doctorow's enshittification cycle is "Then, they die."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#44
post #6

Discord subscriptions seem to be working. People like to customize their profile (ie express themselves), even though profiles are not something frequently interacted with (that's the surprising part!) I have a server (for my game) with about 1000 people. Out of the 300 people logged in, 50 of them have custom profiles. So, it seems like a good idea for Meta.

How’d you make a game with 1,000 people? It’s impressive.

They're players, not devs.

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#45
> There are also other features like Super Heart animated reactions for Stories, custom app icons, customizable fonts for profile bios, and access to additional pins for your profile.

Ahh, remember the days of livejournal/myspace, where we got all of those “features” for free because your profile is literally a fucking webpage

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#47

Interesting. Instagram and Facebook both seem to be filled with AI-generated fake crap today. Even the so-called news items that I see there seem to be fake. I don't even know who would be subscribing. Especially to Facebook as of today.... It is filled with pretty low quality content overall. On the other side, WhatsApp has been getting filled with a lot of bloat. And even today, I find it confusing to use communiti…

> Instagram and Facebook both seem to be filled with AI-generated fake crap today. Also youtube, unfortunately. Google does not understand that AI is slowly killing youtube. I am an expert cat video person, so noticing AI slop is not so hard, but it takes a few seconds (e. g. a mother cat punishing the young cat for "overreach" - the way how the AI video insinuated reality was of course completely false, AI spam slop…

And also, pretty much any internet-generated social media content, basically. Reddit is another classic example. If you look at many posts in subreddits containing a huge number of users, you could easily tell it is AI-generated, especially these idiotic "Am I the asshole" posts or "askreddit" posts and any other posts involving interesting situations.

Not just that. Even comments, some of those are basically AI crap, cleverly disguised as real users. It is such a waste, honestly. AI has brought upon us a low-quality world to live in, out of nowhere. This is such a pity.

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#49
post #11

I would pay $49.99/mo for an unlimited plan that brings me only my friends' status updates (not their hyper-political likes and comments), just their life updates. Daily stories are great too. But JUST that, no influencers, no ads. I realize Meta's data shows that our user revealed preferences tells them that we like all the dopamine hijacking garbage but that's like saying "Well users like drugs, so we gave them mor…

What you need is the Stories feature in Signal, then donate that $49.99/month (or however much you want) to their foundation.

Re: Meta launches Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp subscriptions

#50

Interesting. Instagram and Facebook both seem to be filled with AI-generated fake crap today. Even the so-called news items that I see there seem to be fake. I don't even know who would be subscribing. Especially to Facebook as of today.... It is filled with pretty low quality content overall. On the other side, WhatsApp has been getting filled with a lot of bloat. And even today, I find it confusing to use communiti…

> Instagram and Facebook both seem to be filled with AI-generated fake crap today. Also youtube, unfortunately. Google does not understand that AI is slowly killing youtube. I am an expert cat video person, so noticing AI slop is not so hard, but it takes a few seconds (e. g. a mother cat punishing the young cat for "overreach" - the way how the AI video insinuated reality was of course completely false, AI spam slop…

Shorts are a dumpster fire in terms of fake content. Full length videos are a lot better, as YT has been cracking down on AI generated regular videos, though there are still a fair number of AI narrated/scripted videos and deepfakes of prolific interviewees.
Post reply on HN