Live data from Hacker News

YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos

blog.youtube

591–600 of 881 posts

Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos

#591
post #577
post #570

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Language barrier, sorry. For “even worse” - I meant different, and I think your analogy is unfair. One can say something like “this is not your best job. It is solid product of a carpenter. Even worse, I know you could do much better, like a woodworker”. And nothing here says that the job is _bad_. But again, my native language is not English and the way I say things may surely sound unnatural. —— How going back to y…

> For “even worse” - I meant different Thank you for clarifying. > One can say something like “this is not your best job. It is solid product of a carpenter. Even worse, I know you could do much better, like a woodworker”. And nothing here says that the job is _bad_. Except no, that doesn't make sense. It is not clear at all to say “This is not your best job. It is a solid job. Even worse…”. That is very confusing co…

I am sorry for confusion. I’m typing on the phone and accidentally preessed reply before writing full answer.

I started updating my comment above as soon as I saw that I posted reply (the one that your answer addresses). Hope that clarifies my position and gives you an explanation where I disagree with your comment.

Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos

#592
post #509
post #497

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also the almost industrial score music machines: trailer music, like two steps from hell, even Zimmer. Those are also can be considered as slop, even worse - highly formulaic, almost standard (YouTube “heroic music chord progression”). And those were written by humans

I’m not going to devalue your opinions—music is mostly a matter of taste—but you and your parent comment are stretching the term “slop”, like when a software user misuses “bug” to mean “something which doesn’t work like I want, despite it working exactly as designed for fifteen years”. “Slop” is specifically about AI content lacking in effort, quality, meaning. You may not like Zimmer, but saying it lacks in those ar…

[dead]

Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos

#593
youtube really needs to go. like myspace. Ruined

if they would offer youtube plus, i would pay: - no ads. none. nothing - videos with sponsored content tagged, and option to auto skip - Option to HIDE ALL AI-videos. ALL. And channels. from search also - Option to HIDE ALL slideshow-videos (generated) all. From search also. - Community driven filter list that would auto-update. To hide all the shit content.

Re: YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos

#599

I'm curious where the line is.. several ambiguous but common scenarios: - Occasional AI b-roll during explainer videos - AI generated backing track (music) - AI generated shots sprinkled in a short film - Showing examples of AI video as an AI capability update or commentary

I watched a documentary recently that had an indicator in the top right corner when the content was AI generated. I found it incredibly helpful. Every online video platform should let you label specific segments as AI generated, even better if it is a requirement with validation checks for certain kinds of content.

That’s the creator doing that, right? Is YT going to analyze the whole video and put a label on every frame?
Post reply on HN