Live data from Hacker News

When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

scotusblog.com

11–20 of 76 posts

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#11
In modern politics the end justifies the means.

Are you pro abortion? The end justifies the means, because you are saving women.

Are you pro live? The end justifies the means, because you are saving babies.

As long as the playing field is good vs evil there can't be a rational discussion.

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#12
All that precise language when addressing usually some old guy in black robes (I intentionally put it that way, I'm not in front of the court) reminds me a lot of Japanese formality rules.

It drove me crazy to try to remember and assess not just how to say it in Japanese, but how to change the subject to be honorific, or extra honorific. Or change my own pronoun to ore, boku, watashi, watakushi depending on whether I wanted to try to be intimate or not. Or, remember that damn conjugation rules around converting the sentence to passive, or whatever.

Those rules made me constantly insecure when talking to peers, even when they weren't technically peers. When I did aikido, I was starting as a 1st year in aikido, though I was a 3rd year in college. So, many of my "senpais" were younger but I had to address them a certain way, even when we weren't in the dojo.

All these rules from this article seem like they are designed to give the judges power over the people addressing the court. That seems really strange when I think about it that way. Why do we need to lionize the people, can't their brilliant legal minds carry the full weight of the arguments and decisions?

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#13

The US Supreme Court currently is a joke itself with their Kavanaugh stops laws and other agenda driven politics and mostly in the way the cowardly justices aren’t even providing reasoning or guidance on any of their brain dead rulings to lower courts. The current Supreme Court has no regard for law and justice for the people of the USA. What a joke.

Hey, don’t say that! SCOTUS said it’s bad for the country for them to be perceived as partisan. According to them, the correct fix is to stop describing their partisan actions as partisan.

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#14
post #12

All that precise language when addressing usually some old guy in black robes (I intentionally put it that way, I'm not in front of the court) reminds me a lot of Japanese formality rules. It drove me crazy to try to remember and assess not just how to say it in Japanese, but how to change the subject to be honorific, or extra honorific. Or change my own pronoun to ore, boku, watashi, watakushi depending on whether I…

It is about respect for the institution, regardless of the man. It is why judges are addressed as "your honor" or "judge" as it is to their integrity and their office we plead not to them as individuals.

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#15
post #12

All that precise language when addressing usually some old guy in black robes (I intentionally put it that way, I'm not in front of the court) reminds me a lot of Japanese formality rules. It drove me crazy to try to remember and assess not just how to say it in Japanese, but how to change the subject to be honorific, or extra honorific. Or change my own pronoun to ore, boku, watashi, watakushi depending on whether I…

It is about respect for the institution, regardless of the man. It is why judges are addressed as "your honor" or "judge" as it is to their integrity and their office we plead not to them as individuals.

It is because they have power, and want to be addressed this way. And you are likely to lose your case if you don't follow their rules.

Re: When (if ever) it's appropriate to make jokes before the US Supreme Court

#20
post #17
post #5

The Supreme Court is the joke… it has lost all credibility with partisan inconsistency and overt bribery.

What bribery?

https://www.propublica.org/article/clarence-thomas-money-com...

https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/06/supreme-court-justices-milli...

Etc etc, and that's just one of them, and that's just what's public.

Post reply on HN