Live data from Hacker News

Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

papers.ssrn.com

21–30 of 167 posts

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#21
post #16
post #12

Wait- why isn't there any conflict of interest statement provided in this paper?

Because it's not required and not common practice in our field at this stage. But none of us (I'm one of the authors) is affiliated with or has a financial interest in any prediction market platform.

Isn't it common practice and required to disclose a conflict of interest? Just not to explicitly say there are none.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#22
post #8

Just curious but how are bets arbritated on these website? Meaning who decides if an outcome was yes or no? Answers to things like "Who will win the next Best Picture Oscar?" are fairly obvious and binary. Can we make bets whose answers are not binary yes/no? What about "Will celebraty X and Y break up?"? Does Polymarket go to X and Y to confirm if they broke up or something :D

[deleted]

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#23

[flagged]

I don't think that's surprising because the alternative would be that some people are able to predict the future. Whatever strategy one might figure out that works is long term destined to fail, as other people start using them. The only real way to make money there is by providing liquidity since it's a zero sum game. For the stock market this is not true because it's not zero sum, it grows over time.

Yes, but the alternative (that some people are very good at forecasting) is also plausible. It's also useful to have a good prediction model and timely data sources when providing liquidity. We also find that some of the "biggest losers" also provide liquidity; they just aren't as good at it.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#24

> the top 1% of users capture 76.5% of profits This seems to be similar to OnlyFans, and the economy at large...

these apps should load with this pie chart showing your likelihood of ever making a profit based on what they know about you. "YOU WILL LOSE MONEY ON THIS APP". Like the cigarette packs.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#25

[flagged]

I don't think that's surprising because the alternative would be that some people are able to predict the future. Whatever strategy one might figure out that works is long term destined to fail, as other people start using them. The only real way to make money there is by providing liquidity since it's a zero sum game. For the stock market this is not true because it's not zero sum, it grows over time.

"predicting the future" and "correct analysis of all available information" often aren't all that different.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#26
post #21
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it's not required and not common practice in our field at this stage. But none of us (I'm one of the authors) is affiliated with or has a financial interest in any prediction market platform.

Isn't it common practice and required to disclose a conflict of interest? Just not to explicitly say there are none.

Yes, when you submit for publication. In our field, you rarely see one for pre-prints, unless you have one to disclose.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#28

[flagged]

this comment was clearly written by AI. please don't do that.

Not sure why you were downvoted/flagged, because you're right. It is also quite an insightful comment worthy of discussion so I'm a little conflicted.

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#29

[flagged]

I don't think that's surprising because the alternative would be that some people are able to predict the future. Whatever strategy one might figure out that works is long term destined to fail, as other people start using them. The only real way to make money there is by providing liquidity since it's a zero sum game. For the stock market this is not true because it's not zero sum, it grows over time.

There is alternative to being “able to predict the future”, which is “I already know the future” or “I can change the future”

Re: Who wins and who loses in prediction markets? Evidence from Polymarket

#30
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that's surprising because the alternative would be that some people are able to predict the future. Whatever strategy one might figure out that works is long term destined to fail, as other people start using them. The only real way to make money there is by providing liquidity since it's a zero sum game. For the stock market this is not true because it's not zero sum, it grows over time.

"predicting the future" and "correct analysis of all available information" often aren't all that different.

A sufficiently large market is indistinguishable from Brownian motion.
Post reply on HN