Live data from Hacker News

Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

alqst.org

11–20 of 512 posts

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#11
post #3

The title should read "Saudi Arabia". Cutting a country name in half (unless its an accepted way of abbreviating it) is not a good say of modifying a headline. What is next? Zealand ?

Arabia existed before the Saudis. It will exist after.

Geographically Arabia is more than just Saudi Arabia, so the title is inaccurate.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#13
post #9

Well, it's that or the accounts get removed completely. Sometimes you have to pick your fight, and this doesn't look like one that's worth it.

Not true, there’s a third option: Stop operating in those countries. Which used to be a common choice for tech companies, until it somehow became unthinkable for some reason.

Is it better for human rights for a channel of communication to exist only if every single person can use it? Or is it a net positive for these communication channels to exist, albeit in an imperfect form?

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#15
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Arabia existed before the Saudis. It will exist after.

Geographically Arabia is more than just Saudi Arabia, so the title is inaccurate.

While true, they mentioned another country on the Arabian peninsula so you could assume it is the country.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#16

Well, it's that or the accounts get removed completely. Sometimes you have to pick your fight, and this doesn't look like one that's worth it.

This is a false dichotomy, especially in light of the article mentioning that Twitter hasn't blocked accounts that KSA asked them to block.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#18
Social media companies post record earnings year after year from their ads business while increasingly proving to be harmful to society. They do the bare minimum in terms of content moderation and bots while priming the algorithms to maximize revenue. The good ol' privatized profits, socialized harm model.

In a just world, would social media platforms be taxed higher on corporate revenue and how would that pan out? Maybe we'll be left with small federated platforms without algorithms and ads.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#19
post #7

[flagged]

> now not only are people made redundant, but in a small market like here in Ireland they're outed as a poor performers.

I don't know - I've said before, but the bigger red flag to me would be either that they worked for Meta at all, or that they didn't leave of their own accord. Any big tech company pretending someone was let go, as part of a mass lay-off, for performance reasons is generally going to rate as about as truthful as saying it's "because of AI", if I'm looking at hiring.

Not to erase that Meta is an absolutely shitty company run by a literal ghoul enabled by tens of thousands of "people" who are happy to make giving teenage girls depression in return for ad clicks their entire life's work.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#20
post #9

Well, it's that or the accounts get removed completely. Sometimes you have to pick your fight, and this doesn't look like one that's worth it.

Not true, there’s a third option: Stop operating in those countries. Which used to be a common choice for tech companies, until it somehow became unthinkable for some reason.

Meta has also been regularly nuking/blocking rights-related accounts in countries that do support human rights.

E.g. in The Netherlands. First they did a mass block last December, then again in April:

https://www.at5.nl/artikelen/237924/meta-verwijdert-instagra...

Some were reinstated again, but not all and not after they have been offline for to long.

Post reply on HN