Live data from Hacker News

Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

github.com

101–104 of 104 posts

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#101
post #26

The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. We are well on the way to that path. For almost all materials the only value of getting a seriously produced work of design (i.e., the "make me a magazine-style pitch deck for our seed round" this design engine mentions) is a signaling function that some combination of effor…

I’m glad people will have to evaluate the substance of the deck rather than using a cheap heuristic like how visually appealing the presentation is. I understand there tends to be a correlation between visual appeal and effort, and correlation between effort and merit, but correlation is notoriously flawed. Flawed models can be useful, but only if one qualifies their use sufficiently. I don’t think most people who us…

From Akin's Laws of Spacecraft Design:

A bad design with a good presentation is doomed eventually. A good design with a bad presentation is doomed immediately.

Presentation will always be important as long as humans are involved because we're biologically wired to be attracted to good-looking things. Now I do think that what we associate with "good" will violently change, as it always does (look at fashion).

My guess is that verbosity will be an immediate turnoff, em dashes another immediate turnoff, and we'll value ooga booga conciseness over all other aesthetics. We've already unknowingly begun to move in that direction with the minimalism trend.

Re: Open Design: Use Your Coding Agent as a Design Engine

#103
post #26

The inevitable outcome here is that designed materials become so generic and infinitely produceable that they become worthless background noise. We are well on the way to that path. For almost all materials the only value of getting a seriously produced work of design (i.e., the "make me a magazine-style pitch deck for our seed round" this design engine mentions) is a signaling function that some combination of effor…

As someone who also designs, the few web page designs I saw produced by LLMs were ugly, generic, not accessible… unusable.

Even after prompting, I had to throw away all. No useful ideas just slop.

I’m sure there’s a lot to philosophize about a distant future when these work, but right now a waste of time.

Post reply on HN