Live data from Hacker News

Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

theverge.com

71–80 of 299 posts

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I KNEW I was going to get that wrong.

The mnemonic i use is latitude is flat.

I say longitude goes longways, which I know isn't accurate except fairly close to the poles, but I remembered it like that when I was a kid and it stuck.

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#72

If you're reading this thinking "wow, a recall! tesla must suck at building cars!" then you probably don't know anything about how the automotive industry works and you should refrain from commenting

[flagged]

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#73

What sort of engineering standards are these Cybertrucks built to? Oh, very rigorous engineering standards. The wheels aren't supposed to fall off for a start.

To the ones of people who like to move fast and break things.

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The RWD model was only for sale briefly after launch. I don't know why you would ever want a pure RWD electric truck

Wait until you find out how many gas and diesel powered trucks are RWD! At least in the U.S. below a certain ~longitude~ latitude it's quite common.

[deleted]

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#76

If you're reading this thinking "wow, a recall! tesla must suck at building cars!" then you probably don't know anything about how the automotive industry works and you should refrain from commenting

Do you think these cars are well engineered and reliable?!

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#77

That I can't tell whether "the wheels coming off," is literal or figurative when it comes to Tesla is an indictment about their product quality at this point. What a disaster. I don't really know anyone who is voluntarily buying Teslas when there are so many other viable options in an increasingly crowded marketplace.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48064334

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#78
post #67

If you're reading this thinking "wow, a recall! tesla must suck at building cars!" then you probably don't know anything about how the automotive industry works and you should refrain from commenting

3 verified failures out of 173 total cars is an extremely bad rate for the automotive industry.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48064334

Re: Tesla is recalling its cheaper Cybertruck because the wheels might fall off

#80
post #59

Lest folks get too carried away, the headline is a lie. The failure is "brake rotor stud separating from wheel hub". Now, sure, that's a serious failure. It's not "wh33lz f411 oFF!". Everything about this company is cursed at this point. The jeering masses are just as bad as the CEO. The cars themselves though continue to be really pretty great. Though maybe not the truck.

I'm actually really confused about the language used in the recall; I looked at the Cybertruck manual and the brakes look like a "conventional" design where the studs are set into the hub and go through the rotor, so this failure seems somewhat unrelated to the brake rotors, and the "brake rotor stud" is also the wheel stud: https://service.tesla.com/docs/Cybertruck/ServiceManual/en-u...

I'm assuming it's a misphrasing or typo and the issue is that the stud holes in the wheel hub rotor can elongate, leading to the studs coming out. This can and likely would absolutely cascade into a wheel falling off; I've seen it many times in cheapo endurance racing series - once one stud is loose, the adjacent studs gradually loosen and eventually the wheel separates. If the issue is longitudinal (slotting) it's even more likely to lead to a rapid separation event.

Post reply on HN