Live data from Hacker News

RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

shkspr.mobi

31–40 of 88 posts

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#31
post #23

From my analytics, around 85% of visits to my sites are now from bots. It's hard to say if these are oldschool bots or people just browsing the web via chatgpt now, but the reality is that very few actually visit the actual sites I have anymore.

I think blogs should have a universal comment function, I'd love to engage ith the author but many blogs don't bother providing a basic textarea.

They typically do but are disabled due to the volume of spam and moderation overhead. Send an email.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#32
post #30

How else to notify readers? RSS is quite good. Corporations do not like it though, because they want to control spread of information. They prefer you re-enter page, be targeted with more ads, or spoonfed with their news algorithm on-site. However RSS only works, if someone knows about your page. YouTube is quite good with RSS though. You can have channel RSS, be notified about new videos, while channels still are di…

It’s not that they don’t like it. It’s more like they don’t care, or it’s not on their radar.

Both ideas can be true. It’s not on their radar because despite their popularity in consumer space they can’t find a business purpose that aligns with their self interests that require such user information. If I’m running a free podcast, in contrast, I might be happy anyone’s even bothering to visit and listen to what I have to say compared to who they are and whether I can assign a monetary value to their attention because spending money on something without clear, intentional, measurable ROI is anathema to our predominant modus operandi in business

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#33
post #30

How else to notify readers? RSS is quite good. Corporations do not like it though, because they want to control spread of information. They prefer you re-enter page, be targeted with more ads, or spoonfed with their news algorithm on-site. However RSS only works, if someone knows about your page. YouTube is quite good with RSS though. You can have channel RSS, be notified about new videos, while channels still are di…

It’s not that they don’t like it. It’s more like they don’t care, or it’s not on their radar.

Agree to disagree.

I think many platform did support RSS, or API, but at some time it was dropped. It is not that hard to provide RSS. It is not like it has to be implemented from scratch. It is just dropped by platforms. There must be reasons for dropping. One may argue it is not worth it, but even to drop functionality there needs to be a decision from management. The management always think about money. Is RSS or API monetized correctly? Free? No? Then we drop it, because data from algorithms serving user contents can be easily monetized. Just follow the money, the oldest truth.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#34
post #30

How else to notify readers? RSS is quite good. Corporations do not like it though, because they want to control spread of information. They prefer you re-enter page, be targeted with more ads, or spoonfed with their news algorithm on-site. However RSS only works, if someone knows about your page. YouTube is quite good with RSS though. You can have channel RSS, be notified about new videos, while channels still are di…

It’s not that they don’t like it. It’s more like they don’t care, or it’s not on their radar.

Same difference really.

Though some seem to go out of their way to make RSS impossible.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#35

There's a ton of selection bias going on here. Terence writes mostly about open web standards and topics that would be of significant interest to folks with an RSS feed reader. Also, RSS readers are generally automated. I know I've had them around for years pulling in articles that I never read. Like a podcast "listen" is actually just an automated download, RSS traffic does not necessarily involve anyone actually re…

Right, I'd say RSS numbers (for a given blog post) mostly reflect cumulative visitors over the lifetime of the RSS feed while number of clicks coming in from a search engine reflect instantaneous popularity.

Same pattern as say a sub-reddit subscriber count compared to the number of nicks currently in an associated IRC channel, though IRC lurkers soften that distinction.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#37

Same experience. RSS is by far the most requested resource in the server logs. Sometimes up to 70% of the total traffic is coming from RSS. That said though, I wonder how much of that traffic is biological and how much is bots. I also wonder how much is dead traffic. Dead as in people who add a ton of stuff in their RSS readers but don’t actually read. RSS is a bit of a black box when it comes to this but maybe that'…

I have 220k unread items in my feed reader.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#38
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as a suggestion, but I've been thinking in terms of clustering. If I can figure out that five different posts from five different feeds are about one story, I can collapse them into a single UI element.

I did exactly this with Cohere language embeddings https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/machine-learning/use-language-e...

Thanks! Something to dig into.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#39

Same experience. RSS is by far the most requested resource in the server logs. Sometimes up to 70% of the total traffic is coming from RSS. That said though, I wonder how much of that traffic is biological and how much is bots. I also wonder how much is dead traffic. Dead as in people who add a ton of stuff in their RSS readers but don’t actually read. RSS is a bit of a black box when it comes to this but maybe that'…

> RSS is a bit of a black box when it comes to this

It's not, if you add a tracking parameter in the posted URLs and you keep track of that in your analytics.

Re: RSS feeds send me more traffic than Google

#40

How else to notify readers? RSS is quite good. Corporations do not like it though, because they want to control spread of information. They prefer you re-enter page, be targeted with more ads, or spoonfed with their news algorithm on-site. However RSS only works, if someone knows about your page. YouTube is quite good with RSS though. You can have channel RSS, be notified about new videos, while channels still are di…

I understand your database of feeds is curated but you might be interested in another database listing feeds: Wikidata. See https://w.wiki/MpjN for a simple example of twenty (random) feeds (obviously, you can add filters for e.g. a country, language, etc.). (There are currently 18598 feeds there in total.)
Post reply on HN