Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

tilde.run

21–30 of 147 posts

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#21
post #17
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the repo acts as a source of truth for agents. think memory, data & code. If an agent decides to change any of those, version control allows: 1. to have a human in the loop to approve certain changes 2. rollback changes that end up being incorrect 3. allow reviewing the timeline and history to figure out what changed and how

2. is false. You can't roll back everything an agent does. If you told it to place a trade in the stock market, for example, you can not undo that. That is what I mean by external state. Everything else is covered by existing version control, is it not? What does this buy over that?

indeed - this only applies to the filesystem managed by tilde. Existing version control is fine if you're only managing code. For data (Think large parquet files, millions json files, images and videos, etc), git doesn't scale well for that.

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#22
post #11
post #9

I do not get it. If the agent is not mutating state the change can be checked in. If it is mutating external state, version control won't save you.

the repo acts as a source of truth for agents. think memory, data & code. If an agent decides to change any of those, version control allows: 1. to have a human in the loop to approve certain changes 2. rollback changes that end up being incorrect 3. allow reviewing the timeline and history to figure out what changed and how

Re 2: how do you rollback the (erroneous) action of removing a db table column and the subsequent data loss from the removed column?

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#23

Just my two cents: less is more and the first impression matters a lot. I'm saying this because we see a new agent sandbox tool on the front-page almost every day. Most of them have an AI-made landing page design, lots of animations, lots of words. This has become a bad sign for me. I can tell that you put time into it, made a video, and everything, but I guess I'm suffering from some kind of fatigue of having to go…

Agreed. All of these tools promise the world and are so incredibly vague. Actually show me what I can do with it, like hands on.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDR8tmes020 - a 2 minute hands-on demo!

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#25

I know everyones trying to figure out how to make money in this grift economy, but if you're a rational person, you know that it's all a bunch of gambling and tailoring your scope to b2b and ignoring local & open source models and tools, you're more likely going to be part of that permanent undeclass they keep talking about in a self-fullfilling prophecy.

Sir, this is just one piece of software.

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#26
Interesting project. I am building an IDE for my phone and browser (www.propelcode.app) and have evaluated a few container architectures and providers. It was quite painful to get a prototype working. I will try your platform and would be happy to give feedback.

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#27

Interesting project. I am building an IDE for my phone and browser (www.propelcode.app) and have evaluated a few container architectures and providers. It was quite painful to get a prototype working. I will try your platform and would be happy to give feedback.

Much appreciated! and good luck with your project

Re: Show HN: Tilde.run – Agent sandbox with a transactional, versioned filesystem

#30
I was trying to build an agent. None of the sandboxes out there had solved the filesystem problem. I want my agent to have a persistent storage, and that stays forever. Like a human with a computer. When the agent spins up again, it has access to the computer with the same files.

I had to create my own setup using aws s3 filesystem and docker for this.

Does Tilde solve for this?

Post reply on HN