Live data from Hacker News

Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

mumbaimirror.com

11–20 of 126 posts

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#11
post #6

I hope that people who still think religions "make people better than they would otherwise be" are happy now.

I .. I'm just ashamed of what's happening over here these days. Free speech appears to be an absolute illusion. It's all well and good until you say something even remotely related or critical of a popular personality. Then, it's jungle law.

I don't see religious people disapproving of this and therefore conclude they aren't good. We could probably get a refund on them.

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#12

I hope that people who still think religions "make people better than they would otherwise be" are happy now.

When you generalize like that you're being narrow minded as the people you're criticizing. Instead, like Feynman, you should take what's best from religion to improve yourself, and ignore the rest. History shows the average human being is stupid, so don't be average.

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#13
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really ? The guy tweeting seems legit but even timesofindia has this story: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/21-year-old-girl-ar... Also the vandalism of the clinic definitely happened.

the text is the same, they could just be reposting it from mumbaimirror without a lot fact checking

It seems she was just detained and then released.

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#14
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really ? The guy tweeting seems legit but even timesofindia has this story: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/21-year-old-girl-ar... Also the vandalism of the clinic definitely happened.

the text is the same, they could just be reposting it from mumbaimirror without a lot fact checking

That's quite possible, the copy paste is quite obvious though I don't know for sure which way it went. I don't know who this tweet is from or his credibility so I'll just leave it up in the air for now.

It's still alarming that they were vandalized over a facebook post and the police is looking into possible criminal liability.

Also, the news reports talk specifically of what sections of law the girls were booked under. Doesn't sound so fake because of that.

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#15
post #7

The story is false https://twitter.com/SreenivasanJain/status/27039450506319462...

Really ? The guy tweeting seems legit but even timesofindia has this story: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/21-year-old-girl-ar... Also the vandalism of the clinic definitely happened.

Times of India is a shitty news organization, they're just like Techcrunch, but for the whole nation.

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#16

I hope that people who still think religions "make people better than they would otherwise be" are happy now.

Well, nobody said that about all religions (e.g not for "virgin sacrificing daemon worship" -- though it does sound fun), and for all people practicing them. Christianity didn't make Torquemada any good, but it worked quite well for St. Aquinas.

With that said, the story doesn't have much to do with religion. The guy who funeral they said shouldn't matter was a political leader, not a priest.

The guys that sued/prosecuted the girls did mention "hurting religious sentiments", but that was merely because that was the only semi-plausible accusation under law (since it was a funeral).

In actuality it was a political chase -- people thought they insulted their dear party leader.

(Oh, and it's not like the police arrested them for what they did. The police detained them temporarily just because they had to: that's the law when such an accusation is made, even for someone who didn't do anything).

Re: Mumbai girl arrested for Facebook post

#20

I hope that people who still think religions "make people better than they would otherwise be" are happy now.

When you generalize like that you're being narrow minded as the people you're criticizing. Instead, like Feynman, you should take what's best from religion to improve yourself, and ignore the rest. History shows the average human being is stupid, so don't be average.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN