Live data from Hacker News

Welcome to Gas City

steve-yegge.medium.com

21–30 of 59 posts

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#21
post #10

I really fundamentally do not understand what problem Gas City solves that is not already solved by normal subagent orchestration patterns. If you want to call your main LLM session the "mayor" and have it delegate its work out to planners and coders and reviewers and QA and so on, this is already a thing you can do! If you want to do this in a reusable way you can create skills and subagent definitions and use /comm…

Admittedly, this project started before that was possible with the standard coding agents.

No it didn't!

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#23

You know there are software which are so marvelously monumental, they inspire me to improve in my craft. Among them in no particular order - The Witcher 3 (honorable mention, for all its jank, Skyrim) - Sublime Text and vim - Krita and Procreate - Early Google Chrome - Redis and Postgres Seeing "steve-yegge.medium.com" on the HN frontpage averts me by reflex. Like, I'm suddenly inspired to learn more about agricultur…

What jank does Skyrim have. The whole thing is like 6 GB.

You're thinking of bloat, jank is things like putting a cauldron on your head and the physics engine firing you into the stratosphere.

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#24
If I want to create a furnace into which I can shovel tokens (ie: money) I dont think I can do it quite as elegantly as Gas City.

Its novel and funny, but the hype around agentic coding is bad enough for some engineers to think this represents the pinnacle of current software development practices.

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#25
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He's very transparent about his addiction to agentic coding. He's doing it for the giggles as far as I can tell. Trolling and being a personality. I don't mean that in a bad kind of assessment. He's said as much.

> his addiction to agentic coding Why would it be an addiction versus obsession? Getting obsessed with something and building things around it, even if it's nonsense, is artistically genuine.

It could be either. The bigger critique that people have is that the entire thing is an obvious LARP. None of this is "built for enterprise" or deployed in common ops. This is a zero-risk, zero-judgement project where vanity PRs are encouraged so that another agent can take credit for the vanity fix.

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#26

Let me guess what comes next, Gas State? Where it’s just another larger iteration of the same thing

Deploy packs of Gas Cities with Gas Country! All of that inside our new Gas Planet, where multiple sovereign Gas Countries can cooperate or go to war with each other! All hail our Great Comrade Polecatius of Gasoland, the greatest coding leader of Gas Planet.

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#27
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a good overview source on what this is? I don't want a takedown. And I don't want to be sold. I just want a solid explainer.

I don't know about any ready made explanation, but it is basically multi-agent orchestration, but with lore and role-playing created by a mind deep in AI psychosis. You know how agents can call sub agents? That, but with dozens of different layers and calling things different names for extreme anthropomorphization beyond mortal comprehension. I recommend going deep into the Gas Town rabbit hole, it's really funny and…

[dead]

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> his addiction to agentic coding Why would it be an addiction versus obsession? Getting obsessed with something and building things around it, even if it's nonsense, is artistically genuine.

It could be either. The bigger critique that people have is that the entire thing is an obvious LARP. None of this is "built for enterprise" or deployed in common ops. This is a zero-risk, zero-judgement project where vanity PRs are encouraged so that another agent can take credit for the vanity fix.

> the entire thing is an obvious LARP

Eh, plenty of people play with Sims. Having them do something that feels even tangentially useful has an understandable appeal.

Re: Welcome to Gas City

#29

You know there are software which are so marvelously monumental, they inspire me to improve in my craft. Among them in no particular order - The Witcher 3 (honorable mention, for all its jank, Skyrim) - Sublime Text and vim - Krita and Procreate - Early Google Chrome - Redis and Postgres Seeing "steve-yegge.medium.com" on the HN frontpage averts me by reflex. Like, I'm suddenly inspired to learn more about agricultur…

What jank does Skyrim have. The whole thing is like 6 GB.

It's foolish to even start listing, but here's one: physics bound to FPS
Post reply on HN